Insurance Agent Salary in Buffalo, NY

Updated on May 09, 2025
Position
City
Salary

How much does a Insurance Agent make in Buffalo, NY?

The average salary for a Insurance Agent is $62,528 per year in Buffalo, NY.

In Buffalo, NY, an Insurance Agent can expect to earn a competitive salary. On average, the salary for this role is around $62,528 per year. This figure can vary based on experience, skills, and the type of insurance they specialize in. For those who are just starting, salaries may be lower, but they can grow as they gain more experience.

Insurance Agents in Buffalo have the opportunity to earn more through commissions and bonuses. These additional earnings can significantly increase their total income. For example, top-performing agents often see their salaries rise above the average, especially if they have a strong client base and can sell multiple insurance products. This potential for higher earnings makes the role of an Insurance Agent in Buffalo both challenging and rewarding.

Insurance Agent jobs in Buffalo, NY

What are the highest paying cities for a Insurance Agent near Buffalo, NY?

Job seekers looking for top-paying insurance agent positions near Buffalo, NY, can find excellent opportunities in Albany, NY. Albany offers the highest average salary for this role, making it a prime location for those seeking better compensation. Other nearby cities like Youngstown, OH, and Syracuse, NY, also provide competitive salaries, offering a range of options for professionals in the field.
Graph displaying highest paying cities salaries for Insurance Agent jobs near Buffalo, NY, highlighting Albany, NY with the highest at $75,132 and West Seneca, NY with the lowest at $53,167.
  1. Albany, NY
    Average Salary: $75,132
    Albany offers a vibrant market for insurance professionals. With prominent companies like MVP Health Care and Liberty Mutual, agents can find diverse opportunities. The city's strong economy and growing population make it a great place to build a career.
    Find Insurance Agent jobs in Albany, NY


  2. Youngstown, OH
    Average Salary: $73,291
    In Youngstown, insurance agents can thrive in a community focused on revitalization. Companies like Nationwide and Progressive provide solid opportunities. The city's commitment to growth makes it a promising place for career development.
    Find Insurance Agent jobs in Youngstown, OH


  3. Syracuse, NY
    Average Salary: $72,887
    Syracuse presents a dynamic environment for insurance agents. With major firms like Aetna and HealthNow, there are many avenues to explore. The city's diverse economy offers a stable platform for a successful career.
    Find Insurance Agent jobs in Syracuse, NY


  4. Canton, OH
    Average Salary: $69,887
    Canton is a great place for insurance professionals. Companies like AultCare and Medical Mutual attract many agents. The city's supportive business climate makes it ideal for career growth.
    Find Insurance Agent jobs in Canton, OH


  5. Cleveland, OH
    Average Salary: $68,007
    Cleveland offers a bustling market for insurance agents. With giants like Progressive and Cleveland Clinic Health Plan, there are numerous opportunities. The city's vibrant economy provides a strong foundation for a thriving career.
    Find Insurance Agent jobs in Cleveland, OH


  6. Akron, OH
    Average Salary: $67,942
    Akron provides a thriving environment for insurance professionals. Companies like Summa Health and Blue Cross Blue Shield of Ohio offer many opportunities. The city's growing economy makes it a great place to build a successful career.
    Find Insurance Agent jobs in Akron, OH


  7. Pittsburgh, PA
    Average Salary: $66,843
    Pittsburgh is an excellent city for insurance agents. With companies like Highmark and UPMC Health Plan, there are diverse opportunities. The city's strong economy and rich history create a supportive environment for career growth.
    Find Insurance Agent jobs in Pittsburgh, PA


  8. Erie, PA
    Average Salary: $65,508
    Erie offers a welcoming market for insurance professionals. Companies like Geico and Erie Insurance provide many opportunities. The city's stable economy and friendly community make it a great place for career development.
    Find Insurance Agent jobs in Erie, PA


  9. Rochester, NY
    Average Salary: $64,073
    Rochester presents a vibrant market for insurance agents. With major firms like Excellus BCBS and UnitedHealthcare, there are many opportunities. The city's strong economy and rich cultural scene make it an ideal place for career growth.
    Find Insurance Agent jobs in Rochester, NY


  10. West Seneca, NY
    Average Salary: $53,167
    West Seneca offers a supportive environment for insurance professionals. Companies like MVP Health Care and Fidelis Care provide many opportunities. The city's growing economy and community focus make it a great place for career development.
    Find Insurance Agent jobs in West Seneca, NY

What are the best paying companies for a Insurance Agent in Buffalo, NY?

Comparion Insurance Agency offers one of the best salaries for insurance agents in Buffalo, NY. Their annual pay starts at $77,813. Bankers Life also provides a competitive salary, beginning at $51,750 per year. Both companies present excellent opportunities for those seeking a rewarding career in insurance.
Graph displaying best paying company salaries for Insurance Agent jobs in Buffalo, NY, highlighting Comparion Insurance Agency with the highest at $77,813 and Bankers Life with the lowest at $51,750.
  1. Comparion Insurance Agency
    Average Salary: $77,813
    Comparion Insurance Agency offers rewarding Insurance Agent jobs in Buffalo, NY. They provide a supportive environment for agents to grow and succeed. The agency operates in various locations across the city, ensuring ample opportunities for career advancement.


  2. Bankers Life
    Average Salary: $51,750
    Bankers Life offers Insurance Agent positions in Buffalo, NY, with a focus on life and health insurance. They provide comprehensive training and support to their agents. Bankers Life operates in multiple locations in the city, making it a reliable choice for those seeking stability and growth in their career.

Currently 5,881 Insurance Agent job openings, nationwide.

How's the job market for a Insurance Agent in the US?

Learn what a Insurance Agent does, how to become one, and understand the job outlook. Get simple steps to start your career as a Insurance Agent today.
Position
Overview
Insurance Agent
5,881 Job Openings