Insurance Agent Salary in Lancaster, PA

Updated on May 09, 2025
Position
City
Salary

How much does a Insurance Agent make in Lancaster, PA?

The average salary for a Insurance Agent is $60,106 per year in Lancaster, PA.

In Lancaster, PA, an insurance agent can earn a good salary. On average, an insurance agent makes about $60,106 a year. This amount can change based on experience and the type of insurance they sell. Some agents start with a lower salary, but with more experience, they can earn more.

Insurance agents in Lancaster have different earnings based on their level of experience. For example, those just starting out can make around $36,000. As they gain more experience, they can earn up to $127,500 a year. This range shows that there are good opportunities for growth in this job. It also means that with hard work and dedication, an insurance agent can earn a very good salary over time.

Insurance Agent jobs in Lancaster, PA

What are the highest paying cities for a Insurance Agent near Lancaster, PA?

Job seekers looking for top-paying Insurance Agent jobs near Lancaster, PA, should consider West Chester, PA, where the average salary reaches $83,876. York, PA, offers a solid average salary of $73,370, making it another attractive option. Pottstown, PA, with an average salary of $69,563, also provides a competitive pay package for insurance professionals.
Graph displaying highest paying cities salaries for Insurance Agent jobs near Lancaster, PA, highlighting West Chester, PA with the highest at $83,876 and Souderton, PA with the lowest at $52,500.
  1. West Chester, PA
    Average Salary: $83,876
    In West Chester, insurance professionals thrive in a community that values personalized service. With companies like Nationwide and State Farm, agents enjoy a supportive environment and ample opportunities for growth.
    Find Insurance Agent jobs in West Chester, PA


  2. York, PA
    Average Salary: $73,370
    York offers a dynamic market for insurance agents. The presence of prominent firms such as Allstate and Farmers Insurance provides a solid foundation for building a successful career.
    Find Insurance Agent jobs in York, PA


  3. Pottstown, PA
    Average Salary: $69,563
    Pottstown is a great place for insurance agents to establish their careers. The local market, supported by companies like GEICO and Progressive, offers a stable and rewarding environment.
    Find Insurance Agent jobs in Pottstown, PA


  4. Manheim, PA
    Average Salary: $68,133
    Manheim provides a vibrant setting for insurance professionals. With companies like Liberty Mutual and USAA, agents can leverage a strong network and excellent resources.
    Find Insurance Agent jobs in Manheim, PA


  5. Carlisle, PA
    Average Salary: $67,083
    Carlisle offers a thriving market for insurance agents. The presence of major firms like MetLife and Cigna creates a solid platform for career advancement and client satisfaction.
    Find Insurance Agent jobs in Carlisle, PA


  6. Camp Hill, PA
    Average Salary: $65,116
    Camp Hill is an ideal location for insurance professionals. The area's strong economy, supported by companies like Prudential and American Family Insurance, offers numerous opportunities for growth.
    Find Insurance Agent jobs in Camp Hill, PA


  7. Reading, PA
    Average Salary: $62,945
    Reading provides a dynamic environment for insurance agents. With companies like USAA and Nationwide, agents can build a successful career in a supportive community.
    Find Insurance Agent jobs in Reading, PA


  8. Mechanicsburg, PA
    Average Salary: $61,340
    Mechanicsburg offers a promising market for insurance professionals. The presence of firms like State Farm and Allstate provides a solid foundation for career development and client service.
    Find Insurance Agent jobs in Mechanicsburg, PA


  9. Harrisburg, PA
    Average Salary: $59,062
    Harrisburg is a key location for insurance agents. The city's diverse market, supported by companies like GEICO and Farmers Insurance, offers a wealth of opportunities for growth and success.
    Find Insurance Agent jobs in Harrisburg, PA


  10. Souderton, PA
    Average Salary: $52,500
    Souderton provides a supportive environment for insurance professionals. With companies like Progressive and Allstate, agents can build a rewarding career in a community that values their services.
    Find Insurance Agent jobs in Souderton, PA

What are the best paying companies for a Insurance Agent in Lancaster, PA?

ETS, Inc offers the highest pay for Insurance Agents in Lancaster, PA. The company provides a competitive salary of $127,500 annually. Comparion Insurance Agency also offers a strong salary of $78,167 per year.
Graph displaying best paying company salaries for Insurance Agent jobs in Lancaster, PA, highlighting ETS, Inc with the highest at $127,500 and AAA Central Penn with the lowest at $47,629.
  1. ETS, Inc
    Average Salary: $127,500
    ETS, Inc offers competitive salaries for Insurance Agents in Lancaster, PA. They provide a variety of insurance products and services. The company operates in Lancaster and the surrounding areas, offering a dynamic work environment.


  2. Comparion Insurance Agency
    Average Salary: $78,167
    Comparion Insurance Agency provides a solid salary for Insurance Agents in Lancaster, PA. They focus on personalized insurance solutions. The agency operates in Lancaster and nearby regions, ensuring local market expertise.


  3. The Bagnall Shaw Agency LLC
    Average Salary: $61,833
    The Bagnall Shaw Agency LLC offers a good salary for Insurance Agents in Lancaster, PA. They offer a range of insurance products and services. The agency operates in Lancaster and the surrounding areas, providing a stable work environment.


  4. Allstate Insurance
    Average Salary: $51,902
    Allstate Insurance provides a respectable salary for Insurance Agents in Lancaster, PA. They offer a wide array of insurance products. The company operates in Lancaster and the broader region, ensuring diverse opportunities.


  5. AAA Central Penn
    Average Salary: $47,629
    AAA Central Penn offers a competitive salary for Insurance Agents in Lancaster, PA. They focus on providing quality insurance services. The company operates in Lancaster and the surrounding areas, offering a reliable work environment.

Currently 5,881 Insurance Agent job openings, nationwide.

How's the job market for a Insurance Agent in the US?

Learn what a Insurance Agent does, how to become one, and understand the job outlook. Get simple steps to start your career as a Insurance Agent today.
Position
Overview
Insurance Agent
5,881 Job Openings