Property Manager Salary in Buffalo, NY

Updated on May 09, 2025
Position
City
Salary

How much does a Property Manager make in Buffalo, NY?

The average salary for a Property Manager is $56,504 per year in Buffalo, NY.

A Property Manager in Buffalo, NY, earns a competitive salary. On average, they make around $56,504 per year. This figure can vary based on experience and the specific responsibilities of the role. Those with more experience and a strong track record often earn more.

Factors that can influence a Property Manager's salary include the size of the properties they manage, the location of the properties, and the type of properties. For example, managing a large commercial property may pay more than managing a small residential building. Additionally, Property Managers who handle luxury properties may earn higher salaries. The demand for skilled Property Managers in Buffalo also plays a role in determining salary levels.

Property Manager jobs in Buffalo, NY

What are the highest paying cities for a Property Manager near Buffalo, NY?

Property managers near Buffalo, NY, can find some of the best pay in Batavia, NY, where the average salary is $54,863. Lockport, NY, also offers a high salary of $54,718. Albany, NY, provides a competitive salary of $54,065. These cities present excellent opportunities for those in the field.
Graph displaying highest paying cities salaries for Property Manager jobs near Buffalo, NY, highlighting Batavia, NY with the highest at $54,863 and Syracuse, NY with the lowest at $48,135.
  1. Batavia, NY
    Average Salary: $54,863
    In Batavia, managing properties offers a blend of community charm and professional growth. With local companies like Batavia Downs Gaming and Batavia Industrial Park, you'll find ample opportunities. The area's growing economy makes it a great place to advance your career.
    Find Property Manager jobs in Batavia, NY


  2. Lockport, NY
    Average Salary: $54,718
    Lockport provides a vibrant setting for those managing properties. The city's historic charm meets modern business needs. Companies like Niagara Bottling and Lockport Foundry offer diverse opportunities. Working here means you'll be part of a dynamic community.
    Find Property Manager jobs in Lockport, NY


  3. Albany, NY
    Average Salary: $54,065
    Managing properties in Albany means you'll be at the heart of New York's capital. The city's rich history and bustling business scene create a unique environment. With major firms like New York State Department of Health, you'll have many opportunities to grow and excel.
    Find Property Manager jobs in Albany, NY


  4. Niagara Falls, NY
    Average Salary: $53,681
    Niagara Falls offers a picturesque backdrop for property management. The city's tourism industry thrives, with companies like Niagara Parks and the Niagara Hotel Group. Working here means you'll be part of a vibrant, visitor-focused community.
    Find Property Manager jobs in Niagara Falls, NY


  5. Pittsburgh, PA
    Average Salary: $53,226
    In Pittsburgh, managing properties means you'll be in a city known for its industrial heritage and modern innovation. With companies like U.S. Steel and PPG Industries, you'll find a range of opportunities. The city's growth offers a dynamic career path.
    Find Property Manager jobs in Pittsburgh, PA


  6. Rochester, NY
    Average Salary: $52,333
    Rochester provides a balanced environment for property management. The city's strong healthcare and education sectors offer diverse opportunities. Companies like Rochester Regional Health and the University of Rochester create a supportive professional setting.
    Find Property Manager jobs in Rochester, NY


  7. Cleveland, OH
    Average Salary: $52,022
    In Cleveland, managing properties means you'll be in a city with a rich industrial history and a focus on revitalization. With companies like KeyCorp and the Cleveland Clinic, you'll find many opportunities. The city's growth offers a dynamic career path.
    Find Property Manager jobs in Cleveland, OH


  8. Jamestown, NY
    Average Salary: $49,030
    Jamestown offers a small-town feel with big opportunities in property management. The city's historic charm meets modern business needs. Companies like Jamestown Laundromat and Jamestown Business Incubator provide diverse opportunities. Working here means you'll be part of a supportive community.
    Find Property Manager jobs in Jamestown, NY


  9. Akron, OH
    Average Salary: $48,260
    Akron provides a vibrant setting for those managing properties. The city's rich industrial history and modern growth create a unique environment. Companies like Goodyear Tire and Rubber Company and Summa Health offer diverse opportunities. Working here means you'll be part of a dynamic community.
    Find Property Manager jobs in Akron, OH


  10. Syracuse, NY
    Average Salary: $48,135
    Managing properties in Syracuse means you'll be in a city known for its education and healthcare sectors. With companies like Syracuse University and St. Joseph's Health, you'll find many opportunities. The city's growth offers a dynamic career path.
    Find Property Manager jobs in Syracuse, NY

What are the best paying companies for a Property Manager in Buffalo, NY?

Ciminelli Real Estate Corporation offers one of the highest salaries for Property Managers in Buffalo, NY, with an average of $81,500 per year. Equity Lifestyle Properties and CyberCoders also provide competitive pay, with averages of $77,333 and $75,000 respectively. These companies present excellent opportunities for those seeking a rewarding career in property management.
Graph displaying best paying company salaries for Property Manager jobs in Buffalo, NY, highlighting Ciminelli Real Estate Corporation with the highest at $81,500 and KCG Companies, LLC with the lowest at $56,333.
  1. Ciminelli Real Estate Corporation
    Average Salary: $81,500
    Ciminelli Real Estate Corporation offers Property Manager jobs in Buffalo, NY, with a focus on residential and commercial properties. The company operates throughout Western New York, providing a variety of management opportunities.


  2. Equity Lifestyle Properties
    Average Salary: $77,333
    Equity Lifestyle Properties provides Property Manager jobs in Buffalo, NY, with a focus on senior living communities. The company operates across the United States, offering diverse management roles.


  3. CyberCoders
    Average Salary: $75,000
    CyberCoders offers Property Manager jobs in Buffalo, NY, with a focus on various property types. The company operates nationwide, providing a range of management positions.


  4. Benderson Development
    Average Salary: $66,911
    Benderson Development offers Property Manager jobs in Buffalo, NY, with a focus on residential and commercial properties. The company operates in multiple states, offering diverse management opportunities.


  5. The United Group of Companies, Inc.
    Average Salary: $65,333
    The United Group of Companies, Inc. provides Property Manager jobs in Buffalo, NY, with a focus on residential and commercial properties. The company operates in the Northeast, offering a variety of management roles.


  6. California Commercial Investment Group
    Average Salary: $59,000
    California Commercial Investment Group offers Property Manager jobs in Buffalo, NY, with a focus on commercial properties. The company operates across the country, providing diverse management opportunities.


  7. DePaul Community Services
    Average Salary: $58,107
    DePaul Community Services offers Property Manager jobs in Buffalo, NY, with a focus on affordable housing. The company operates in several states, providing a range of management roles.


  8. Tarantino Properties, Inc.
    Average Salary: $57,000
    Tarantino Properties, Inc. provides Property Manager jobs in Buffalo, NY, with a focus on residential properties. The company operates in the Northeast, offering diverse management opportunities.


  9. Beacon Communities LLC
    Average Salary: $56,517
    Beacon Communities LLC offers Property Manager jobs in Buffalo, NY, with a focus on senior living communities. The company operates in the Northeast, providing a variety of management roles.


  10. KCG Companies, LLC
    Average Salary: $56,333
    KCG Companies, LLC provides Property Manager jobs in Buffalo, NY, with a focus on residential and commercial properties. The company operates in the Northeast, offering diverse management opportunities.

Currently 5,970 Property Manager job openings, nationwide.

How's the job market for a Property Manager in the US?

Learn what a Property Manager does, how to become one, and understand the job outlook. Get simple steps to start your career as a Property Manager today.
Position
Overview
Property Manager
5,970 Job Openings