Server Server Salary in Lancaster, NY

Server Salary in Lancaster, NY

Updated on Oct 10, 2026
Position
City
Salary

How much does a Server make in Lancaster, NY?

The average salary for a Server is $31,459 per year in Lancaster, NY.
Yearly
Monthly
Weekly
Hourly
Graph depicting the yearly salary distribution for Server jobs in Lancaster, NY, showing an average salary of $31,459 with varying distribution percentages across salary ranges.
Graph depicting the monthly salary distribution for Server jobs in Lancaster, NY, showing an average salary of $2,622 with varying distribution percentages across salary ranges.
Graph depicting the weekly salary distribution for Server jobs in Lancaster, NY, showing an average salary of $605 with varying distribution percentages across salary ranges.
Graph depicting the hourly salary distribution for Server jobs in Lancaster, NY, showing an average salary of $15 with varying distribution percentages across salary ranges.

A server in Lancaster, NY, typically makes an average yearly salary of $31,459. This job role involves serving food and drinks to customers in restaurants and other food service establishments. The salary can vary based on experience and the specific establishment.


Here are some salary details to consider:

  • About 72% of servers earn between $25,248 and $31,745 annually.
  • 15% earn slightly more, between $31,745 and $32,827.
  • A small percentage, around 7%, earn less than $25,248 per year.
  • The highest earners, around 5%, make over $32,827 annually.

Server jobs in Lancaster, NY
View all Server jobs in Lancaster, NY

What are the highest paying cities for a Server near Lancaster, NY?

Job seekers around Lancaster, NY, can find promising opportunities in nearby cities. Depew and West Seneca offer competitive average salaries for server jobs, making them attractive options. East Aurora, Elma, and Hamburg also provide solid pay scales for those in the server role. Each of these cities provides a range of establishments seeking skilled servers. Buffalo, the largest city listed, might have a higher cost of living, but it also offers the highest average salary at 34,776. Considering these factors can help job seekers make informed decisions.
Graph displaying highest paying cities salaries for Server jobs near Lancaster, NY, highlighting Depew, NY with the highest at $45,200 and Buffalo, NY with the lowest at $34,776.

  1. Depew, NY
    Average Salary: $45,200
    In Depew, working as a server offers a mix of quick service and family dining experiences. Popular spots like diners and casual restaurants create a lively atmosphere. Job seekers can look forward to steady work hours and the chance to build a solid resume.
    Find Server jobs in Depew, NY


  2. West Seneca, NY
    Average Salary: $41,120
    West Seneca provides a variety of dining options that serve as great places for servers to work. From local eateries to larger chains, servers here enjoy a dynamic work environment. The community-focused restaurants offer a chance to meet and connect with regular customers.
    Find Server jobs in West Seneca, NY


  3. East Aurora, NY
    Average Salary: $38,888
    Server jobs in East Aurora often involve working in cozy family-run restaurants and cafes. The area’s laid-back vibe makes for a pleasant work environment. With a mix of dinner service and brunch shifts, servers can find a variety of opportunities.
    Find Server jobs in East Aurora, NY


  4. Elma, NY
    Average Salary: $38,400
    Elma offers a small-town charm where servers can enjoy a close-knit community. The local diners and casual restaurants provide a welcoming environment. Servers can expect a friendly atmosphere and the chance to know regular customers.
    Find Server jobs in Elma, NY


  5. Hamburg, NY
    Average Salary: $37,208
    Hamburg provides a mix of rural and suburban dining options. Servers here can enjoy working in family-owned restaurants and local eateries. The area’s welcoming nature makes it a pleasant place for servers to develop their skills.
    Find Server jobs in Hamburg, NY


  6. Tonawanda, NY
    Average Salary: $36,369
    Tonawanda’s dining scene includes a mix of classic diners and modern restaurants. Servers can expect to work in a variety of settings, from casual to more formal. The area’s diverse food options provide many opportunities for professional growth.
    Find Server jobs in Tonawanda, NY


  7. Williamsville, NY
    Average Salary: $36,332
    In Williamsville, servers can find work in a range of casual dining and upscale restaurants. The area’s vibrant food culture offers plenty of variety. Servers can enjoy working in a community that values hospitality and service.
    Find Server jobs in Williamsville, NY


  8. Scotia, NY
    Average Salary: $35,760
    Scotia offers a variety of dining options, from small cafes to larger establishments. Servers here can expect a friendly environment and the chance to serve a diverse clientele. The local atmosphere makes for enjoyable work shifts.
    Find Server jobs in Scotia, NY


  9. Clarence, NY
    Average Salary: $35,450
    Clarence provides a mix of casual and family-style dining options. Servers can enjoy working in a community that values service. The local restaurants offer a warm and welcoming atmosphere for both servers and guests.
    Find Server jobs in Clarence, NY


  10. Buffalo, NY
    Average Salary: $34,776
    Buffalo offers a bustling dining scene with a wide range of options for servers. From downtown hotspots to suburban restaurants, there are plenty of opportunities to work in a dynamic environment. The city’s vibrant food culture ensures a steady flow of customers.
    Find Server jobs in Buffalo, NY

What are the best paying companies for a Server in Lancaster, NY?

Elderwood offers competitive pay for server positions in Lancaster, NY, with an average salary of about $35,507. CrossAmerica Partners LP also provides a solid salary of around $32,100 for those interested in server roles. Brazen Roofing pays an average of $25,550 for servers, making it another option to consider.
Graph displaying best paying company salaries for Server jobs in Lancaster, NY, highlighting Elderwood with the highest at $35,507 and Brazen Roofing with the lowest at $25,550.

  1. Elderwood
    Average Salary: $35,507
    Elderwood offers a range of positions for servers in their Lancaster location. They value teamwork and ensure their servers work in a collaborative environment. Elderwood operates in multiple locations, providing a stable career path with opportunities for growth.


  2. CrossAmerica Partners LP
    Average Salary: $32,100
    CrossAmerica Partners LP provides server positions that focus on customer service excellence. This company is part of a larger network and offers servers the chance to work in various locations. Their training programs are designed to support professional development.


  3. Brazen Roofing
    Average Salary: $25,550
    Brazen Roofing offers server roles that support their operations in Lancaster and other areas. This company emphasizes a strong work ethic and provides servers with the skills needed to succeed in a dynamic work environment. They are known for their dedication to quality and customer satisfaction.

Currently 14,814 Server job openings, nationwide.

View Server Jobs in Lancaster, NY

How's the job market for a Server in the US?

Learn what a Server does, how to become one, and understand the job outlook. Get simple steps to start your career as a Server today.
Position
Overview
Server
14,814 Job Openings

Win at hiring.

Visit the help center for any questions.
Contact Support
ReadySetHire icon
©2025 • ReadySetHire