Shift Leader Salary in Amherst, NY

Updated on May 09, 2025
Position
City
Salary

How much does a Shift Leader make in Amherst, NY?

The average salary for a Shift Leader is $35,100 per year in Amherst, NY.

A Shift Leader in Amherst, NY, earns a good salary. The average salary for this role is around $35,100 per year. This means that many Shift Leaders in the area make close to this amount. The salary can vary based on experience and the specific company.

Shift Leaders in Amherst, NY, have a range of salaries. The lowest-paid Shift Leaders earn around $30,000 per year. Those with more experience or in higher-paying industries can earn up to $39,000 or more. The salary range shows that there are good opportunities for those who work hard and gain experience. This can lead to higher earnings over time.

Shift Leader jobs in Amherst, NY

What are the highest paying cities for a Shift Leader near Amherst, NY?

Job seekers looking for Shift Leader roles near Amherst, NY, can find attractive opportunities in nearby cities. Buffalo, NY, offers the highest average salary at $39,270. Grand Island, NY, and Orchard Park, NY, follow closely with salaries of $38,600 and $36,641, respectively. These cities provide a range of industries with competitive pay for those in leadership positions.
Graph displaying highest paying cities salaries for Shift Leader jobs near Amherst, NY, highlighting Buffalo, NY with the highest at $39,270 and Hamburg, NY with the lowest at $34,670.
  1. Buffalo, NY
    Average Salary: $39,270
    Buffalo offers a dynamic environment for those in leadership roles. With major companies like Wegmans and Tops Markets, leaders here manage teams effectively. The city's rich culture and strong community spirit make it a rewarding place to work.
    Find Shift Leader jobs in Buffalo, NY


  2. Grand Island, NY
    Average Salary: $38,600
    In Grand Island, leading a team means working in a close-knit community. Companies like Niagara Bottling and Tops Friendly Markets value strong leadership. The area's peaceful setting provides a balanced work-life environment.
    Find Shift Leader jobs in Grand Island, NY


  3. Orchard Park, NY
    Average Salary: $36,641
    Orchard Park is known for its sports culture and community events. Leaders here manage teams in a supportive environment. With companies like Wegmans and local businesses, the area offers a unique blend of work and community life.
    Find Shift Leader jobs in Orchard Park, NY


  4. Lackawanna, NY
    Average Salary: $36,000
    Lackawanna provides a vibrant setting for leadership roles. Companies like Tops Markets and local enterprises value effective team management. The city's growing economy offers many opportunities for career growth.
    Find Shift Leader jobs in Lackawanna, NY


  5. Rochester, NY
    Average Salary: $35,302
    Rochester is a hub for innovation and leadership. With major employers like Wegmans and Blue Cross Blue Shield, leaders here drive team success. The city's diverse culture and strong economy make it an exciting place to work.
    Find Shift Leader jobs in Rochester, NY


  6. Tonawanda, NY
    Average Salary: $35,279
    Tonawanda offers a friendly environment for team leaders. Companies like Tops Markets and local businesses value strong leadership. The area's community spirit and growing economy provide a supportive work setting.
    Find Shift Leader jobs in Tonawanda, NY


  7. Syracuse, NY
    Average Salary: $35,217
    Syracuse is a city of opportunities for leaders. With companies like Wegmans and local enterprises, leaders here manage teams effectively. The city's rich history and vibrant culture make it a rewarding place to work.
    Find Shift Leader jobs in Syracuse, NY


  8. Williamsville, NY
    Average Salary: $35,186
    Williamsville offers a welcoming environment for leadership roles. Companies like Tops Markets and local businesses value strong team management. The area's peaceful setting and strong community spirit provide a balanced work-life environment.
    Find Shift Leader jobs in Williamsville, NY


  9. Niagara Falls, NY
    Average Salary: $35,052
    Niagara Falls provides a scenic backdrop for leadership roles. With companies like Wegmans and local enterprises, leaders here manage teams effectively. The area's natural beauty and vibrant community make it a unique place to work.
    Find Shift Leader jobs in Niagara Falls, NY


  10. Hamburg, NY
    Average Salary: $34,670
    Hamburg offers a supportive environment for team leaders. Companies like Tops Markets and local businesses value strong leadership. The area's peaceful setting and strong community spirit provide a balanced work-life environment.
    Find Shift Leader jobs in Hamburg, NY

What are the best paying companies for a Shift Leader in Amherst, NY?

Job seekers in Amherst, NY, looking for a Shift Leader role can find good opportunities with WellNow Urgent Care. This company offers a competitive salary of $40,000 per year. Walgreens and Wegmans Food Markets also provide attractive pay packages, with salaries around $36,083 and $34,913, respectively. Kwik Fill offers a salary of $30,225. These companies value their shift leaders and offer good compensation for the role.
Graph displaying best paying company salaries for Shift Leader jobs in Amherst, NY, highlighting WellNow Urgent Care with the highest at $40,000 and Kwik Fill with the lowest at $30,225.
  1. WellNow Urgent Care
    Average Salary: $40,000
    WellNow Urgent Care offers a dynamic environment for Shift Leaders. They operate multiple locations in Amherst, NY, providing urgent care services. The role involves overseeing daily operations, managing staff, and ensuring high-quality patient care.


  2. Walgreens
    Average Salary: $36,083
    Walgreens is a well-known pharmacy chain with several locations in Amherst, NY. Shift Leaders at Walgreens manage store operations, supervise staff, and ensure customer satisfaction. The role requires strong leadership skills and a commitment to excellent service.


  3. Wegmans Food Markets
    Average Salary: $34,913
    Wegmans Food Markets is a popular grocery store with locations in Amherst, NY. Shift Leaders here manage store staff, oversee daily operations, and ensure a positive shopping experience for customers. The role is ideal for those who enjoy a fast-paced retail environment.


  4. Kwik Fill
    Average Salary: $30,225
    Kwik Fill is a convenience store chain with locations in Amherst, NY. Shift Leaders at Kwik Fill manage store operations, supervise staff, and ensure a smooth shopping experience for customers. The role involves working in a busy retail setting and requires strong organizational skills.

Currently 14,982 Shift Leader job openings, nationwide.

How's the job market for a Shift Leader in the US?

Learn what a Shift Leader does, how to become one, and understand the job outlook. Get simple steps to start your career as a Shift Leader today.
Position
Overview
Shift Leader
14,982 Job Openings