Shift Leader Salary in Garden City, NY

Updated on May 09, 2025
Position
City
Salary

How much does a Shift Leader make in Garden City, NY?

The average salary for a Shift Leader is $36,166 per year in Garden City, NY.

A Shift Leader in Garden City, NY, earns an average salary of around $36,166 per year. This figure can vary based on experience, the specific industry, and the size of the company. Shift Leaders often manage teams, ensure smooth operations, and handle customer service issues during their shifts. Their role is crucial in maintaining productivity and morale within the workplace.

The salary range for Shift Leaders in Garden City, NY, typically falls between $34,000 and $40,000 annually. Those with more experience or additional responsibilities may earn towards the higher end of this range. Benefits such as health insurance, retirement plans, and paid time off can also enhance the overall compensation package. This position offers a stable career path with opportunities for advancement.

Shift Leader jobs in Garden City, NY

What are the highest paying cities for a Shift Leader near Garden City, NY?

Job seekers looking for a Shift Leader role near Garden City, NY, can find attractive opportunities in nearby cities. Westbury, NY, offers the highest average salary at $48,880. This makes it a prime location for those seeking better compensation. Other nearby cities like Farmingdale and North Bellmore also provide competitive pay, making them good options to consider.
Graph displaying highest paying cities salaries for Shift Leader jobs near Garden City, NY, highlighting Westbury, NY with the highest at $48,880 and Carle Place, NY with the lowest at $34,140.
  1. Westbury, NY
    Average Salary: $48,880
    In Westbury, NY, leading a team can be a rewarding experience. Many local businesses value strong leadership skills. Companies like Westbury Diner and local retail stores often seek experienced leaders.
    Find Shift Leader jobs in Westbury, NY


  2. Farmingdale, NY
    Average Salary: $41,077
    Farmingdale, NY, offers a vibrant community for team leaders. The area has a mix of retail and service businesses. Companies such as Dunkin' and local grocery stores look for dependable leaders.
    Find Shift Leader jobs in Farmingdale, NY


  3. North Bellmore, NY
    Average Salary: $37,333
    North Bellmore, NY, provides a supportive environment for team leaders. The area has many small businesses and local shops. Companies like North Bellmore Pharmacy and nearby restaurants value effective leadership.
    Find Shift Leader jobs in North Bellmore, NY


  4. Uniondale, NY
    Average Salary: $37,067
    Uniondale, NY, is a bustling area for team leaders. The city has a variety of businesses, including restaurants and retail stores. Companies such as Uniondale Market and local eateries often seek skilled leaders.
    Find Shift Leader jobs in Uniondale, NY


  5. Hempstead, NY
    Average Salary: $36,600
    Hempstead, NY, offers diverse opportunities for team leaders. The city has a mix of businesses, from retail to service. Companies like Hempstead Grocery and local cafes look for experienced leaders.
    Find Shift Leader jobs in Hempstead, NY


  6. Long Beach, NY
    Average Salary: $36,000
    Long Beach, NY, is a vibrant city for team leaders. The area has many restaurants and shops. Companies such as Long Beach Diner and local businesses often seek strong leaders.
    Find Shift Leader jobs in Long Beach, NY


  7. Albertson, NY
    Average Salary: $35,818
    Albertson, NY, provides a welcoming environment for team leaders. The city has a variety of small businesses. Companies like Albertson Market and local eateries value effective leadership.
    Find Shift Leader jobs in Albertson, NY


  8. Valley Stream, NY
    Average Salary: $35,750
    Valley Stream, NY, offers many opportunities for team leaders. The area has a mix of retail and service businesses. Companies such as Valley Stream Pharmacy and local restaurants look for skilled leaders.
    Find Shift Leader jobs in Valley Stream, NY


  9. Elmont, NY
    Average Salary: $35,361
    Elmont, NY, is a great place for team leaders. The city has many local businesses. Companies like Elmont Market and nearby restaurants often seek experienced leaders.
    Find Shift Leader jobs in Elmont, NY


  10. Carle Place, NY
    Average Salary: $34,140
    Carle Place, NY, provides a supportive environment for team leaders. The area has a variety of businesses, from retail to service. Companies such as Carle Place Pharmacy and local cafes look for dependable leaders.
    Find Shift Leader jobs in Carle Place, NY

What are the best paying companies for a Shift Leader in Garden City, NY?

Sweetgreen offers the highest salary for Shift Leader positions in Garden City, NY, with an average of $39,075 per year. Laderach USA and Walgreens also provide competitive salaries, around $38,125 and $38,000 respectively. Le Pain Quotidien and Melt Shop offer salaries of $38,000 and $34,000 annually. These companies value their shift leaders and offer attractive compensation packages.
Graph displaying best paying company salaries for Shift Leader jobs in Garden City, NY, highlighting Sweetgreen with the highest at $39,075 and Melt Shop with the lowest at $34,000.
  1. Sweetgreen
    Average Salary: $39,075
    Sweetgreen offers exciting Shift Leader jobs in Garden City. This company focuses on fresh, seasonal salads. They have locations in many cities across the U.S. Working here means you will help manage daily operations and ensure a great customer experience.


  2. Laderach USA
    Average Salary: $38,125
    Laderach USA provides rewarding Shift Leader positions in Garden City. They specialize in premium chocolate products. This company operates in various locations nationwide. As a Shift Leader, you will oversee store staff and maintain high standards of service.


  3. Walgreens
    Average Salary: $38,000
    Walgreens offers competitive Shift Leader salaries in Garden City. They are a well-known pharmacy chain with stores across the country. In this role, you will manage store staff, handle inventory, and ensure customer satisfaction.


  4. Le Pain Quotidien
    Average Salary: $38,000
    Le Pain Quotidien provides excellent Shift Leader opportunities in Garden City. This company is famous for its fresh, handmade bread and pastries. They have locations in many cities. As a Shift Leader, you will manage daily operations and ensure a welcoming atmosphere for customers.


  5. Melt Shop
    Average Salary: $34,000
    Melt Shop offers Shift Leader jobs in Garden City. They focus on gourmet grilled cheese sandwiches. This company operates in several locations. As a Shift Leader, you will oversee staff, manage inventory, and ensure a high-quality customer experience.

Currently 14,982 Shift Leader job openings, nationwide.

How's the job market for a Shift Leader in the US?

Learn what a Shift Leader does, how to become one, and understand the job outlook. Get simple steps to start your career as a Shift Leader today.
Position
Overview
Shift Leader
14,982 Job Openings