Shift Leader Salary in Middleton, WI

Updated on May 09, 2025
Position
City
Salary

How much does a Shift Leader make in Middleton, WI?

The average salary for a Shift Leader is $34,223 per year in Middleton, WI.

A Shift Leader in Middleton, WI, earns a competitive salary. The average annual salary for this role is around $34,223. This figure can vary based on experience, skills, and the specific employer. Shift Leaders often manage teams, ensuring that daily operations run smoothly.

Factors that can influence salary include the size of the company, the industry, and additional responsibilities. For instance, a Shift Leader in a larger retail chain might earn more than one in a smaller local business. Experience also plays a key role. Those with more years in the role or in similar positions can expect higher pay. Additionally, Shift Leaders who take on extra duties, such as training new staff or handling inventory, may see a salary increase. This role is a great opportunity for those looking to advance in their career while earning a fair wage.

Shift Leader jobs in Middleton, WI

What are the highest paying cities for a Shift Leader near Middleton, WI?

Job seekers looking for Shift Leader positions near Middleton, WI, can find high-paying opportunities in nearby cities. Madison, WI, stands out with an average salary of $46,367. This makes it a prime location for those seeking better compensation. Other cities like Stoughton and Oregon also offer competitive salaries, making them attractive options.
Graph displaying highest paying cities salaries for Shift Leader jobs near Middleton, WI, highlighting New Glarus, WI with the highest at $46,367 and Portage, WI with the lowest at $34,554.
  1. New Glarus, WI
    Average Salary: $46,367
    In New Glarus, leading a team offers a unique experience with local businesses. The community's focus on quality and craftsmanship makes it a great place to work. Companies like New Glarus Brewing provide a welcoming environment for team leaders.
    Find Shift Leader jobs in New Glarus, WI


  2. Stoughton, WI
    Average Salary: $36,292
    Stoughton presents a vibrant setting for team leaders. The city's strong local economy and community spirit create a supportive environment. Working with businesses like Stoughton Trailers can be fulfilling and rewarding.
    Find Shift Leader jobs in Stoughton, WI


  3. Oregon, WI
    Average Salary: $36,000
    Oregon offers a close-knit community for those in leadership roles. The local businesses value teamwork and dedication. Leading a team here can be both challenging and enjoyable.
    Find Shift Leader jobs in Oregon, WI


  4. Madison, WI
    Average Salary: $35,852
    Madison is a dynamic city for team leaders. The diverse job market and vibrant culture provide many opportunities. Companies like Epic Systems offer a professional environment for growth.
    Find Shift Leader jobs in Madison, WI


  5. Waunakee, WI
    Average Salary: $35,381
    Waunakee provides a peaceful setting for team leaders. The community is supportive and the local businesses are growing. Leading a team here can be both rewarding and enjoyable.
    Find Shift Leader jobs in Waunakee, WI


  6. Baraboo, WI
    Average Salary: $35,319
    Baraboo offers a charming environment for team leaders. The city's strong community ties and local businesses create a supportive workplace. Leading a team here can be both fulfilling and enjoyable.
    Find Shift Leader jobs in Baraboo, WI


  7. Sun Prairie, WI
    Average Salary: $35,130
    Sun Prairie presents a growing environment for team leaders. The city's expanding economy and community spirit make it a great place to work. Companies like Snap-on offer a professional setting for leadership.
    Find Shift Leader jobs in Sun Prairie, WI


  8. Monona, WI
    Average Salary: $34,791
    Monona offers a vibrant setting for team leaders. The city's strong community and local businesses provide a supportive environment. Leading a team here can be both challenging and rewarding.
    Find Shift Leader jobs in Monona, WI


  9. Delafield, WI
    Average Salary: $34,778
    Delafield provides a welcoming environment for team leaders. The city's strong community and local businesses create a supportive workplace. Leading a team here can be both fulfilling and enjoyable.
    Find Shift Leader jobs in Delafield, WI


  10. Portage, WI
    Average Salary: $34,554
    Portage offers a dynamic setting for team leaders. The city's strong local economy and community spirit make it a great place to work. Companies like Kohler Co. offer a professional environment for growth.
    Find Shift Leader jobs in Portage, WI

What are the best paying companies for a Shift Leader in Middleton, WI?

Walgreens, Jersey Mike's, Border Foods, and Cafe Zupas offer some of the best pay for Shift Leaders in Middleton, WI. Walgreens leads the pack with an average salary of $36,000. Jersey Mike's follows closely with an average salary of $35,173. Border Foods and Cafe Zupas also provide competitive salaries, with $32,863 and $32,631 respectively. These companies value their Shift Leaders and offer attractive compensation packages.
Graph displaying best paying company salaries for Shift Leader jobs in Middleton, WI, highlighting Walgreens with the highest at $36,000 and Cafe Zupas with the lowest at $32,631.
  1. Walgreens
    Average Salary: $36,000
    Walgreens offers rewarding Shift Leader positions in Middleton, WI. As a Shift Leader, you will manage store operations, oversee staff, and ensure a great customer experience. Walgreens operates nationwide, providing a stable and reputable environment for career growth.


  2. Jersey Mike's
    Average Salary: $35,173
    Jersey Mike's provides exciting Shift Leader roles in Middleton, WI. In this role, you will lead a team, handle customer service, and maintain store quality. Jersey Mike's is a popular sandwich chain with locations across the United States, offering a dynamic work environment.


  3. Border Foods
    Average Salary: $32,863
    Border Foods is looking for dedicated Shift Leaders in Middleton, WI. You will supervise daily operations, manage staff, and ensure customer satisfaction. Border Foods operates in the Midwest, providing a community-focused work experience.


  4. Cafe Zupas
    Average Salary: $32,631
    Cafe Zupas offers Shift Leader positions in Middleton, WI. As a Shift Leader, you will oversee restaurant operations, manage staff, and ensure a welcoming atmosphere for customers. Cafe Zupas is a fast-casual restaurant chain with locations in several states.

Currently 14,982 Shift Leader job openings, nationwide.

How's the job market for a Shift Leader in the US?

Learn what a Shift Leader does, how to become one, and understand the job outlook. Get simple steps to start your career as a Shift Leader today.
Position
Overview
Shift Leader
14,982 Job Openings