Substitute Teacher Salary in Rochester, NY

Updated on May 09, 2025
Position
City
Salary

How much does a Substitute Teacher make in Rochester, NY?

The average salary for a Substitute Teacher is $39,595 per year in Rochester, NY.

A Substitute Teacher in Rochester, NY, can expect to earn a competitive salary. On average, these educators make around $39,595 per year. This figure reflects the range of salaries from entry-level to more experienced positions. The salary can vary based on factors such as the school district, the level of education, and the specific needs of the school.

The salary range for Substitute Teachers in Rochester, NY, starts from about $30,000 for those just starting out. As experience grows, so does the salary. Teachers with more years in the field can earn up to $53,800. This range shows that there are opportunities for growth and advancement in this career. It also highlights the value placed on experienced educators who can step in seamlessly to support students' learning.

Substitute Teacher jobs in Rochester, NY

What are the highest paying cities for a Substitute Teacher near Rochester, NY?

Substitute Teacher jobs offer a rewarding career with competitive pay. Near Rochester, NY, Buffalo, NY, and Albany, NY, stand out as top-paying cities. Buffalo offers the highest average salary at $50,018, followed by Albany at $48,493. These cities provide excellent opportunities for those seeking higher earnings in the education sector.
Graph displaying highest paying cities salaries for Substitute Teacher jobs near Rochester, NY, highlighting Sodus, NY with the highest at $64,062 and Batavia, NY with the lowest at $36,722.
  1. Sodus, NY
    Average Salary: $64,062
    In Sodus, teaching offers a chance to work with a tight-knit community. Schools here value educators who can adapt to different classrooms. The Sodus Central School District is a prominent employer.
    Find Substitute Teacher jobs in Sodus, NY


  2. Buffalo, NY
    Average Salary: $50,018
    Buffalo provides a dynamic environment for educators. The city's diverse schools offer many opportunities to make an impact. Buffalo Public Schools is a key employer in the area.
    Find Substitute Teacher jobs in Buffalo, NY


  3. Albany, NY
    Average Salary: $48,493
    Working in Albany means joining a historic city with a strong educational focus. The Albany Public Schools offer diverse teaching experiences. The district is known for its commitment to student success.
    Find Substitute Teacher jobs in Albany, NY


  4. Schenectady, NY
    Average Salary: $46,387
    Schenectady offers a vibrant community for educators. The Schenectady City School District provides many opportunities to work with motivated students. The district is dedicated to academic excellence.
    Find Substitute Teacher jobs in Schenectady, NY


  5. Poughkeepsie, NY
    Average Salary: $46,071
    In Poughkeepsie, teaching allows you to be part of a growing community. The Poughkeepsie City School District values educators who can inspire students. The district offers a supportive environment for professional growth.
    Find Substitute Teacher jobs in Poughkeepsie, NY


  6. Lockport, NY
    Average Salary: $43,561
    Lockport provides a welcoming environment for educators. The Lockport City School District offers many opportunities to connect with students. The district is known for its strong community involvement.
    Find Substitute Teacher jobs in Lockport, NY


  7. Canandaigua, NY
    Average Salary: $42,374
    Canandaigua offers a peaceful setting for teaching. The Canandaigua City School District provides a supportive environment for educators. The district values teachers who can engage and motivate students.
    Find Substitute Teacher jobs in Canandaigua, NY


  8. Ithaca, NY
    Average Salary: $39,757
    Ithaca provides a vibrant and intellectual environment for educators. The Ithaca City School District offers diverse teaching opportunities. The district is known for its commitment to academic excellence and community involvement.
    Find Substitute Teacher jobs in Ithaca, NY


  9. Syracuse, NY
    Average Salary: $37,989
    Syracuse offers a dynamic and diverse environment for educators. The Syracuse City School District provides many opportunities to work with a wide range of students. The district is dedicated to student success and professional development.
    Find Substitute Teacher jobs in Syracuse, NY


  10. Batavia, NY
    Average Salary: $36,722
    Batavia offers a supportive and engaging environment for educators. The Batavia City School District provides many opportunities to connect with students. The district values teachers who can inspire and motivate young minds.
    Find Substitute Teacher jobs in Batavia, NY

What are the best paying companies for a Substitute Teacher in Rochester, NY?

Substitute teachers in Rochester, NY, can find rewarding positions with Our Lady of Mercy School for Young Women, which offers a competitive salary of $44,447. Easter Seals also provides a solid pay of $43,000. Norman Howard School pays $42,310, making it another attractive option. These schools value their educators and offer competitive compensation packages.
Graph displaying best paying company salaries for Substitute Teacher jobs in Rochester, NY, highlighting Our Lady of Mercy School for Young Women with the highest at $44,447 and Allendale Columbia School with the lowest at $32,067.
  1. Our Lady of Mercy School for Young Women
    Average Salary: $44,447
    Our Lady of Mercy School for Young Women offers competitive pay for Substitute Teachers. They provide a nurturing environment for students in Rochester, NY. Their focus on academic excellence makes them a great choice for educators looking to make a difference.


  2. Easter Seals
    Average Salary: $43,000
    Easter Seals is known for its commitment to inclusivity and support for individuals with disabilities. They offer a supportive work environment for Substitute Teachers in Rochester, NY. Working here means contributing to a meaningful cause while earning a solid salary.


  3. Norman Howard School
    Average Salary: $42,310
    Norman Howard School provides a diverse educational setting for students in Rochester, NY. They value their Substitute Teachers and offer a competitive salary. This school emphasizes student success and offers a rewarding work environment.


  4. Senya
    Average Salary: $38,125
    Senya offers Substitute Teacher positions with a focus on innovation and student engagement. They operate in Rochester, NY, and provide a dynamic work environment. This company is ideal for educators who enjoy a fast-paced setting.


  5. CP Rochester
    Average Salary: $33,125
    CP Rochester provides Substitute Teacher opportunities with a focus on community and education. They operate in Rochester, NY, and offer a supportive work environment. This company is a good fit for those looking for a stable and community-focused role.


  6. Allendale Columbia School
    Average Salary: $32,067
    Allendale Columbia School offers Substitute Teacher positions with a focus on academic achievement. They operate in Rochester, NY, and provide a nurturing environment for students. This school is a great choice for educators who value a supportive community.

Currently 2,176 Substitute Teacher job openings, nationwide.

How's the job market for a Substitute Teacher in the US?

Learn what a Substitute Teacher does, how to become one, and understand the job outlook. Get simple steps to start your career as a Substitute Teacher today.
Position
Overview
Substitute Teacher
2,176 Job Openings