Insurance Agent Salary in Pittsburgh, PA

Updated on May 09, 2025
Position
City
Salary

How much does a Insurance Agent make in Pittsburgh, PA?

The average salary for a Insurance Agent is $66,843 per year in Pittsburgh, PA.

In Pittsburgh, PA, an Insurance Agent can expect to earn a competitive salary. The average annual salary for this role is around $66,843. This figure can vary based on experience, skills, and the specific company. Entry-level positions may start at around $36,000, while more experienced agents can earn upwards of $124,500.

Several factors influence the salary of an Insurance Agent in Pittsburgh. These include the type of insurance products they sell, their ability to meet sales targets, and their customer service skills. Agents who specialize in high-demand areas like health or life insurance often see higher earnings. Networking and building strong client relationships also play a crucial role in achieving higher income levels.

Insurance Agent jobs in Pittsburgh, PA

What are the highest paying cities for a Insurance Agent near Pittsburgh, PA?

Job seekers looking for top-paying Insurance Agent positions near Pittsburgh, PA, should consider cities like Youngstown, OH, and Toledo, OH. These cities offer competitive salaries, with Youngstown topping the list at $73,291. Nearby cities such as Dayton, OH, and Cincinnati, OH, also provide attractive compensation packages. These locations present excellent opportunities for those seeking rewarding careers in the insurance industry.
Graph displaying highest paying cities salaries for Insurance Agent jobs near Pittsburgh, PA, highlighting Youngstown, OH with the highest at $73,291 and Erie, PA with the lowest at $65,508.
  1. Youngstown, OH
    Average Salary: $73,291
    In Youngstown, insurance professionals enjoy a community-focused work environment. Companies like Nationwide and Progressive offer opportunities to build strong client relationships. The area's diverse economy provides a variety of insurance needs.
    Find Insurance Agent jobs in Youngstown, OH


  2. Toledo, OH
    Average Salary: $72,327
    Toledo offers a stable market for insurance agents. With prominent firms such as American Family Insurance, agents can thrive by understanding local needs. The city's strong community ties enhance client trust and loyalty.
    Find Insurance Agent jobs in Toledo, OH


  3. Dayton, OH
    Average Salary: $71,820
    Dayton provides a dynamic setting for insurance agents. Companies like State Farm and Farmers Insurance are well-established. The area's growing population offers many opportunities to expand one's client base.
    Find Insurance Agent jobs in Dayton, OH


  4. Cincinnati, OH
    Average Salary: $70,149
    Cincinnati is a vibrant city for insurance professionals. Major companies like Cincinnati Insurance and Nationwide are present. The diverse market allows agents to specialize in various insurance sectors.
    Find Insurance Agent jobs in Cincinnati, OH


  5. Greensburg, PA
    Average Salary: $68,416
    Greensburg offers a close-knit community for insurance agents. Local firms like Erie Insurance provide a supportive environment. The area's smaller size allows for strong personal connections with clients.
    Find Insurance Agent jobs in Greensburg, PA


  6. Cleveland, OH
    Average Salary: $68,007
    Cleveland presents a bustling market for insurance agents. Companies such as Progressive and American Century Insurance are key players. The city's diverse economic landscape offers many opportunities for growth.
    Find Insurance Agent jobs in Cleveland, OH


  7. Akron, OH
    Average Salary: $67,942
    Akron provides a stable environment for insurance professionals. With companies like Allstate and Nationwide, agents can build lasting client relationships. The city's strong community focus enhances job satisfaction.
    Find Insurance Agent jobs in Akron, OH


  8. Columbus, OH
    Average Salary: $67,787
    Columbus offers a thriving market for insurance agents. Major firms like Nationwide and American Family Insurance are present. The city's diverse economy provides many opportunities to meet various insurance needs.
    Find Insurance Agent jobs in Columbus, OH


  9. Indianapolis, IN
    Average Salary: $66,302
    Indianapolis is a dynamic city for insurance professionals. Companies like State Farm and Farmers Insurance are well-established. The area's growing population offers many opportunities for agents to expand their client base.
    Find Insurance Agent jobs in Indianapolis, IN


  10. Erie, PA
    Average Salary: $65,508
    Erie offers a supportive community for insurance agents. With local firms like Erie Insurance, agents can build strong client relationships. The area's smaller size allows for deep personal connections with clients.
    Find Insurance Agent jobs in Erie, PA

What are the best paying companies for a Insurance Agent in Pittsburgh, PA?

Job seekers looking for top-paying insurance agent positions in Pittsburgh, PA, should consider companies like American Senior Benefits and Advocate Health Advisors. These firms offer competitive salaries, with American Senior Benefits leading at $111,150. Advocate Health Advisors follows closely with an annual salary of $96,157. Both companies provide excellent opportunities for career growth and financial stability.
Graph displaying best paying company salaries for Insurance Agent jobs in Pittsburgh, PA, highlighting American Senior Benefits with the highest at $111,150 and The Lewis Financial Group with the lowest at $65,000.
  1. American Senior Benefits
    Average Salary: $111,150
    American Senior Benefits offers rewarding Insurance Agent jobs in Pittsburgh, PA. They focus on senior insurance solutions. They operate in multiple locations, including Pittsburgh, to serve their clients.


  2. Advocate Health Advisors
    Average Salary: $96,157
    Advocate Health Advisors provides Insurance Agent positions with a competitive salary. They specialize in health insurance and operate in various locations, including Pittsburgh, to meet client needs.


  3. ABN Financial Group
    Average Salary: $87,500
    ABN Financial Group offers Insurance Agent jobs with a solid salary. They provide a range of financial services and operate in several locations, including Pittsburgh, to support their clients.


  4. Spartan Financial
    Average Salary: $83,600
    Spartan Financial offers Insurance Agent jobs with a good salary. They focus on financial planning and operate in multiple locations, including Pittsburgh, to assist their clients.


  5. Comparion Insurance Agency
    Average Salary: $82,438
    Comparion Insurance Agency provides Insurance Agent positions with a competitive salary. They offer various insurance solutions and operate in several locations, including Pittsburgh, to serve their clients.


  6. New York Life
    Average Salary: $73,592
    New York Life offers Insurance Agent jobs with a respectable salary. They are a well-known insurance company and operate in various locations, including Pittsburgh, to support their clients.


  7. Aflac
    Average Salary: $68,686
    Aflac provides Insurance Agent positions with a good salary. They specialize in supplemental insurance and operate in multiple locations, including Pittsburgh, to meet client needs.


  8. JB Vending LLC
    Average Salary: $65,000
    JB Vending LLC offers Insurance Agent jobs with a standard salary. They focus on vending services and operate in several locations, including Pittsburgh, to support their clients.


  9. Lewis Financial
    Average Salary: $65,000
    Lewis Financial provides Insurance Agent positions with a standard salary. They offer financial services and operate in multiple locations, including Pittsburgh, to assist their clients.


  10. The Lewis Financial Group
    Average Salary: $65,000
    The Lewis Financial Group offers Insurance Agent jobs with a standard salary. They focus on financial planning and operate in several locations, including Pittsburgh, to support their clients.

Currently 5,881 Insurance Agent job openings, nationwide.

How's the job market for a Insurance Agent in the US?

Learn what a Insurance Agent does, how to become one, and understand the job outlook. Get simple steps to start your career as a Insurance Agent today.
Position
Overview
Insurance Agent
5,881 Job Openings