Property Manager Salary in Indianapolis, IN

Updated on May 09, 2025
Position
City
Salary

How much does a Property Manager make in Indianapolis, IN?

The average salary for a Property Manager is $50,049 per year in Indianapolis, IN.

In Indianapolis, IN, a Property Manager can expect to earn a competitive salary. The average annual salary for this role is around $50,000. This figure can vary based on experience, the size of the properties managed, and the specific responsibilities of the job. Those with more experience and those who manage larger properties often earn more.

Property Managers in Indianapolis can earn salaries ranging from about $31,500 to over $80,000 per year. The lower end of the range typically includes entry-level positions, while the higher end includes senior roles with significant responsibilities. Some Property Managers also earn bonuses and other benefits, which can increase their total compensation.

Property Manager jobs in Indianapolis, IN

What are the highest paying cities for a Property Manager near Indianapolis, IN?

Property managers near Indianapolis, IN, can find some of the best pay in Fishers, where the average salary is $68,354. Carmel offers a close second with an average salary of $54,960. Noblesville, Seymour, and Westfield also provide competitive salaries, making these cities attractive for job seekers in the field. These cities offer not only higher salaries but also a strong demand for property management services, providing excellent opportunities for professionals in the industry.
Graph displaying highest paying cities salaries for Property Manager jobs near Indianapolis, IN, highlighting Fishers, IN with the highest at $68,354 and Lafayette, IN with the lowest at $46,527.
  1. Fishers, IN
    Average Salary: $68,354
    In Fishers, managing properties can lead to a rewarding career. The area is known for its growing community and strong local businesses. Companies like Carmel Properties offer great opportunities for those in the field.
    Find Property Manager jobs in Fishers, IN


  2. Carmel, IN
    Average Salary: $54,960
    Carmel provides a vibrant environment for property management. The city's focus on community and development makes it a great place to work. Local firms like Carmel Properties are always on the lookout for skilled managers.
    Find Property Manager jobs in Carmel, IN


  3. Noblesville, IN
    Average Salary: $49,722
    Noblesville is a city where property management thrives. The area is known for its friendly residents and growing economy. Companies such as Carmel Properties offer excellent career paths for those in the industry.
    Find Property Manager jobs in Noblesville, IN


  4. Seymour, IN
    Average Salary: $49,354
    Seymour offers a unique setting for property management. The city's blend of rural charm and urban amenities makes it an interesting place to work. Local businesses are always in need of experienced managers.
    Find Property Manager jobs in Seymour, IN


  5. Westfield, IN
    Average Salary: $48,217
    In Westfield, managing properties can be a fulfilling career. The city's growing population and strong community spirit create a positive work environment. Companies like Carmel Properties provide great opportunities.
    Find Property Manager jobs in Westfield, IN


  6. Greenwood, IN
    Average Salary: $47,707
    Greenwood is a city where property management is in high demand. The area's economic growth and community focus make it an ideal place to work. Local firms like Carmel Properties offer excellent career prospects.
    Find Property Manager jobs in Greenwood, IN


  7. Gary, IN
    Average Salary: $47,630
    Gary offers a dynamic environment for property management. The city's revitalization efforts and community engagement make it a great place to work. Companies such as Carmel Properties are always looking for skilled managers.
    Find Property Manager jobs in Gary, IN


  8. Bloomington, IN
    Average Salary: $47,615
    Bloomington provides a vibrant setting for property management. The city's strong educational institutions and community focus create a positive work environment. Local businesses are always in need of experienced managers.
    Find Property Manager jobs in Bloomington, IN


  9. Fort Wayne, IN
    Average Salary: $47,107
    Fort Wayne is a city where property management can lead to a successful career. The area's economic growth and community spirit make it an ideal place to work. Companies like Carmel Properties offer great opportunities.
    Find Property Manager jobs in Fort Wayne, IN


  10. Lafayette, IN
    Average Salary: $46,527
    Lafayette offers a unique environment for property management. The city's blend of urban and rural settings makes it an interesting place to work. Local businesses are always looking for skilled managers.
    Find Property Manager jobs in Lafayette, IN

What are the best paying companies for a Property Manager in Indianapolis, IN?

Job seekers looking for Property Manager roles in Indianapolis, IN, can find top-paying opportunities with M&M Property Management, offering an average salary of $70,000. RealAmerica Development and Coastal Ridge Real Estate also provide competitive salaries, with averages around $67,000. These companies stand out for their attractive compensation packages, making them excellent choices for those in the industry.
Graph displaying best paying company salaries for Property Manager jobs in Indianapolis, IN, highlighting M&M Property Management with the highest at $70,000 and Flaherty & Collins Properties with the lowest at $55,183.
  1. M&M Property Management
    Average Salary: $70,000
    M&M Property Management offers Property Manager jobs in Indianapolis, IN. They manage residential and commercial properties. Their properties are located throughout Indianapolis.


  2. RealAmerica Development
    Average Salary: $67,900
    RealAmerica Development provides Property Manager jobs in Indianapolis, IN. They focus on residential and commercial real estate. Their properties are spread across the city.


  3. Coastal Ridge Real Estate
    Average Salary: $66,870
    Coastal Ridge Real Estate has Property Manager jobs in Indianapolis, IN. They manage a variety of properties. Their locations include many areas of Indianapolis.


  4. Cornerstone Companies, Inc
    Average Salary: $66,786
    Cornerstone Companies, Inc. offers Property Manager jobs in Indianapolis, IN. They manage residential and commercial properties. Their properties are located throughout the city.


  5. Morgan Properties
    Average Salary: $59,513
    Morgan Properties provides Property Manager jobs in Indianapolis, IN. They manage residential and commercial properties. Their locations include many areas of Indianapolis.


  6. Cushman & Wakefield
    Average Salary: $59,045
    Cushman & Wakefield offers Property Manager jobs in Indianapolis, IN. They manage residential and commercial properties. Their properties are located throughout the city.


  7. SHEEHAN PROPERTY MANAGEMENT
    Average Salary: $58,029
    SHEEHAN PROPERTY MANAGEMENT provides Property Manager jobs in Indianapolis, IN. They manage residential and commercial properties. Their locations include many areas of Indianapolis.


  8. Kittle Property Group, Inc.
    Average Salary: $56,123
    Kittle Property Group, Inc. offers Property Manager jobs in Indianapolis, IN. They manage residential and commercial properties. Their properties are located throughout the city.


  9. Muesing Management Company
    Average Salary: $55,600
    Muesing Management Company provides Property Manager jobs in Indianapolis, IN. They manage residential and commercial properties. Their locations include many areas of Indianapolis.


  10. Flaherty & Collins Properties
    Average Salary: $55,183
    Flaherty & Collins Properties offers Property Manager jobs in Indianapolis, IN. They manage residential and commercial properties. Their properties are located throughout the city.

Currently 5,970 Property Manager job openings, nationwide.

How's the job market for a Property Manager in the US?

Learn what a Property Manager does, how to become one, and understand the job outlook. Get simple steps to start your career as a Property Manager today.
Position
Overview
Property Manager
5,970 Job Openings