Server Server Salary in Bay Shore, NY

Server Salary in Bay Shore, NY

Updated on Mar 10, 2026
Position
City
Salary

How much does a Server make in Bay Shore, NY?

The average salary for a Server is $37,124 per year in Bay Shore, NY.
Yearly
Monthly
Weekly
Hourly
Graph depicting the yearly salary distribution for Server jobs in Bay Shore, NY, showing an average salary of $37,124 with varying distribution percentages across salary ranges.
Graph depicting the monthly salary distribution for Server jobs in Bay Shore, NY, showing an average salary of $3,094 with varying distribution percentages across salary ranges.
Graph depicting the weekly salary distribution for Server jobs in Bay Shore, NY, showing an average salary of $714 with varying distribution percentages across salary ranges.
Graph depicting the hourly salary distribution for Server jobs in Bay Shore, NY, showing an average salary of $18 with varying distribution percentages across salary ranges.

In Bay Shore, NY, servers earn a variety of salaries depending on experience and other factors. The average yearly salary for a server in this area is around $37,124. This figure varies, with some servers earning closer to $20,000 and others making up to $78,000 annually.

Different percentages of servers fall into different pay brackets. For example, the largest portion, about 33.71%, earn between $30,545 and $35,818. Another 21.45% make between $25,273 and $30,545. On the higher end, 6.13% earn between $62,182 and $72,727. These numbers show that while the average salary is a good benchmark, there is a wide range of earnings based on individual circumstances.

Server jobs in Bay Shore, NY
View all Server jobs in Bay Shore, NY

What are the highest paying cities for a Server near Bay Shore, NY?

Server jobs near Bay Shore, NY, offer good salaries, with Hauppauge leading at $71,383 on average. Babylon and North Babylon follow closely, with average salaries also well above $39,000. These nearby cities present strong opportunities for those seeking high-paying server positions. Explore these nearby towns for competitive server roles. Dix Hills, Commack, and Lindenhurst offer average server salaries between $36,000 and $40,000. This range makes them attractive for job seekers looking to balance earnings and proximity to Bay Shore.
Graph displaying highest paying cities salaries for Server jobs near Bay Shore, NY, highlighting Hauppauge, NY with the highest at $71,383 and Sayville, NY with the lowest at $34,095.

  1. Hauppauge, NY
    Average Salary: $71,383
    In Hauppauge, server roles involve serving food and drinks with a focus on efficiency and customer service. Prominent restaurants, like American Flatbread and The Melting Pot, offer competitive wages and opportunities for growth.
    Find Server jobs in Hauppauge, NY


  2. Babylon, NY
    Average Salary: $46,502
    Working in Babylon, servers will serve patrons in a busy environment. Local spots such as Joe Allen and the Babylon Diner provide a dynamic atmosphere and the chance to grow in a well-known setting.
    Find Server jobs in Babylon, NY


  3. North Babylon, NY
    Average Salary: $39,625
    In North Babylon, servers play a key role in providing excellent service in a variety of dining environments. Local favorites like 1412 Restaurant and Bar and Bella Luna offer opportunities to excel in a bustling community.
    Find Server jobs in North Babylon, NY


  4. Deer Park, NY
    Average Salary: $39,013
    Servers in Deer Park enjoy working in a laid-back setting, serving guests in a variety of establishments. Places like Cafe 21 and The Green House provide a chance to grow and develop in a friendly environment.
    Find Server jobs in Deer Park, NY


  5. Dix Hills, NY
    Average Salary: $38,326
    Dix Hills offers a mix of fine dining and casual spots where servers can thrive. Working at establishments like The Grill at The Landing or Blue Ginger Sushi & Noodle gives servers a chance to grow in a vibrant community.
    Find Server jobs in Dix Hills, NY


  6. Commack, NY
    Average Salary: $36,161
    In Commack, servers find themselves in upscale settings, providing top-notch service to patrons. Dining establishments such as The Black Trumpet and The Lobster House offer competitive wages and growth opportunities.
    Find Server jobs in Commack, NY


  7. Lindenhurst, NY
    Average Salary: $35,106
    Lindenhurst is home to a variety of dining options where servers can excel. From casual eateries to fine dining, local spots like The Brick Oven Bistro and Seabreeze Grill provide a dynamic work environment.
    Find Server jobs in Lindenhurst, NY


  8. Ronkonkoma, NY
    Average Salary: $34,580
    Ronkonkoma offers a mix of casual and fine dining experiences for servers. Working at places like The Melting Pot or American Flatbread allows servers to develop their skills in a busy setting.
    Find Server jobs in Ronkonkoma, NY


  9. West Babylon, NY
    Average Salary: $34,271
    In West Babylon, servers will thrive in a lively dining scene. Local favorites like Joe Allen and Bella Luna provide a chance for servers to grow and excel in a dynamic community.
    Find Server jobs in West Babylon, NY


  10. Sayville, NY
    Average Salary: $34,095
    Sayville presents a mix of casual and fine dining opportunities for servers. Working at places like The Lobster House or Blue Ginger Sushi & Noodle gives servers a chance to grow in a friendly environment.
    Find Server jobs in Sayville, NY

What are the best paying companies for a Server in Bay Shore, NY?

Looking for a server job in Bay Shore, NY? Buffalo Wild Wings offers one of the highest salaries at $43,560. Atria Senior Living and The Cheesecake Factory also provide competitive wages. Both companies pay around $35,044 and $25,563 respectively, making them attractive options for job seekers.
Graph displaying best paying company salaries for Server jobs in Bay Shore, NY, highlighting Buffalo Wild Wings with the highest at $43,560 and The Cheesecake Factory with the lowest at $25,563.

  1. Buffalo Wild Wings
    Average Salary: $43,560
    Buffalo Wild Wings offers rewarding Server jobs. This company provides a vibrant work environment in Bay Shore, NY. Servers get to engage with customers while serving food and drinks. Buffalo Wild Wings emphasizes teamwork and a fun atmosphere.


  2. Atria Senior Living
    Average Salary: $35,044
    Atria Senior Living provides Server positions with a focus on hospitality. Located in Bay Shore, NY, Servers work in dining areas for the residents. The company offers a friendly and caring work environment. Staff get to interact with seniors, making each day meaningful.


  3. The Cheesecake Factory
    Average Salary: $25,563
    The Cheesecake Factory offers Server roles in Bay Shore, NY. Servers play a key role in providing great customer service. The job involves taking orders, serving food, and ensuring guests have a pleasant dining experience. The Cheesecake Factory has a lively and enjoyable workplace.

Currently 18,672 Server job openings, nationwide.

View Server Jobs in Bay Shore, NY

How's the job market for a Server in the US?

Learn what a Server does, how to become one, and understand the job outlook. Get simple steps to start your career as a Server today.
Position
Overview
Server
18,672 Job Openings

Win at hiring.

Visit the help center for any questions.
Contact Support
ReadySetHire icon
©2025 • ReadySetHire