Server Server Salary in Bay Shore, NY

Server Salary in Bay Shore, NY

Updated on Jan 12, 2026
Position
City
Salary

How much does a Server make in Bay Shore, NY?

The average salary for a Server is $35,721 per year in Bay Shore, NY.
Yearly
Monthly
Weekly
Hourly
Graph depicting the yearly salary distribution for Server jobs in Bay Shore, NY, showing an average salary of $35,721 with varying distribution percentages across salary ranges.
Graph depicting the monthly salary distribution for Server jobs in Bay Shore, NY, showing an average salary of $2,977 with varying distribution percentages across salary ranges.
Graph depicting the weekly salary distribution for Server jobs in Bay Shore, NY, showing an average salary of $687 with varying distribution percentages across salary ranges.
Graph depicting the hourly salary distribution for Server jobs in Bay Shore, NY, showing an average salary of $17 with varying distribution percentages across salary ranges.

Servers in Bay Shore, NY, play a crucial role in the restaurant industry. They interact with customers, take orders, and serve food and drinks. Understanding the average salary for this job can help someone decide if it suits them.

On average, a server in Bay Shore earns about $35,721 per year. This average takes into account all experience levels. Some servers earn more, and some earn less, depending on their skills and the restaurant they work at. Servers often receive tips, which can add a good amount to their total pay. The best-paid servers in Bay Shore make up to $78,000 annually.

When looking at a server job, consider the following factors that can affect your salary:

  • Type of restaurant: Upscale places may pay more.
  • Location: Centrally located spots may see more customers.
  • Tips: Good servers usually get better tips.
  • Experience: More experienced servers often earn more.

Server jobs in Bay Shore, NY
View all Server jobs in Bay Shore, NY

What are the highest paying cities for a Server near Bay Shore, NY?

Job seekers can find great opportunities for server positions near Bay Shore, NY. For those looking for higher salaries, Hauppauge and Babylon offer some of the best wages. With an average salary of $71,808 in Hauppauge and $48,548 in Babylon, these cities stand out as top locations for server jobs in the area. Exploring other nearby cities also reveals good earning potential. North Babylon, Dix Hills, and Deer Park offer competitive salaries. North Babylon provides an average of $38,740, Dix Hills pays around $38,596, and Deer Park offers $36,928. These figures show promising options for those seeking well-paid server roles near Bay Shore, NY.
Graph displaying highest paying cities salaries for Server jobs near Bay Shore, NY, highlighting Hauppauge, NY with the highest at $71,808 and West Babylon, NY with the lowest at $33,841.

  1. Hauppauge, NY
    Average Salary: $71,808
    Jobs as a server in Hauppauge offer a chance to work in a vibrant community. Many restaurants and cafes seek skilled server staff. Companies like The Breakfast Club and local eateries provide opportunities.
    Find Server jobs in Hauppauge, NY


  2. Babylon, NY
    Average Salary: $48,548
    In Babylon, servers can find positions in family-friendly eateries and popular restaurants. Positions in well-known places can lead to good experience and tips. Places like The Keg Steakhouse and local diners are hiring.
    Find Server jobs in Babylon, NY


  3. North Babylon, NY
    Average Salary: $38,740
    North Babylon offers jobs where servers can meet diverse customers. Many local restaurants look for friendly and hard-working staff. Working at places like The Friendly Toasted and family restaurants can be fulfilling.
    Find Server jobs in North Babylon, NY


  4. Dix Hills, NY
    Average Salary: $38,596
    Dix Hills has plenty of opportunities for servers in various dining establishments. Many restaurants focus on quality service and customer satisfaction. Opportunities exist at places like The Prime Rib and other local spots.
    Find Server jobs in Dix Hills, NY


  5. Deer Park, NY
    Average Salary: $36,928
    In Deer Park, servers can work in both casual and fine dining settings. Local restaurants value teamwork and customer service. Working at places like The Red Robin or local cafes offers good experience.
    Find Server jobs in Deer Park, NY


  6. Commack, NY
    Average Salary: $36,567
    Commack provides a pleasant environment for servers. Many restaurants focus on great service and customer experience. Positions at places like The Old Firehouse Pub and local diners are available.
    Find Server jobs in Commack, NY


  7. Lindenhurst, NY
    Average Salary: $34,920
    Lindenhurst offers jobs where servers can interact with a variety of customers. Many local restaurants are known for their friendly service. Opportunities exist at places like The Corner Bistro and other local eateries.
    Find Server jobs in Lindenhurst, NY


  8. Ronkonkoma, NY
    Average Salary: $34,313
    Ronkonkoma has many opportunities for servers in both casual and fine dining settings. Many local restaurants emphasize good service and teamwork. Positions at places like The Blue Moon and local cafes are available.
    Find Server jobs in Ronkonkoma, NY


  9. Sayville, NY
    Average Salary: $34,099
    In Sayville, servers can find positions in many local restaurants and cafes. The community values good service and customer experience. Working at places like The Local Taphouse and other eateries can be rewarding.
    Find Server jobs in Sayville, NY


  10. West Babylon, NY
    Average Salary: $33,841
    West Babylon provides a variety of opportunities for server positions. Many restaurants emphasize teamwork and customer satisfaction. Positions at places like The Crab Shanty and other local dining spots are available.
    Find Server jobs in West Babylon, NY

What are the best paying companies for a Server in Bay Shore, NY?

Buffalo Wild Wings offers some of the best paying server jobs in Bay Shore, NY, with an average salary of $43,560. This restaurant chain values its servers and offers competitive pay to attract the best talent. Atria Senior Living also provides strong compensation, with an average server salary of $35,044. This organization focuses on providing excellent care, and its pay reflects that commitment. The Cheesecake Factory, with an average server salary of $25,235, rounds out the top companies in the area. This renowned chain ensures a rewarding work environment for its servers.
Graph displaying best paying company salaries for Server jobs in Bay Shore, NY, highlighting Buffalo Wild Wings with the highest at $43,560 and The Cheesecake Factory with the lowest at $25,235.

  1. Buffalo Wild Wings
    Average Salary: $43,560
    Buffalo Wild Wings offers rewarding Server positions. Servers here provide a friendly and lively experience, often in a fast-paced environment. They focus on delivering excellent service to guests in Bay Shore, NY, and other locations.


  2. Atria Senior Living
    Average Salary: $35,044
    Atria Senior Living provides Server jobs with a unique focus. Servers work in dining areas of senior living communities, ensuring residents enjoy their meals. This role values hospitality and compassion. Atria operates in Bay Shore, NY, and other areas.


  3. The Cheesecake Factory
    Average Salary: $25,235
    The Cheesecake Factory offers Server roles that emphasize customer service. Servers take orders, serve food, and ensure guests have a delightful dining experience. This company runs many locations, including Bay Shore, NY.

Currently 14,001 Server job openings, nationwide.

View Server Jobs in Bay Shore, NY

How's the job market for a Server in the US?

Learn what a Server does, how to become one, and understand the job outlook. Get simple steps to start your career as a Server today.
Position
Overview
Server
14,001 Job Openings

Win at hiring.

Visit the help center for any questions.
Contact Support
ReadySetHire icon
©2025 • ReadySetHire