Server Server Salary in Bay Shore, NY

Server Salary in Bay Shore, NY

Updated on Jun 10, 2026
Position
City
Salary

How much does a Server make in Bay Shore, NY?

The average salary for a Server is $39,869 per year in Bay Shore, NY.
Yearly
Monthly
Weekly
Hourly
Graph depicting the yearly salary distribution for Server jobs in Bay Shore, NY, showing an average salary of $39,869 with varying distribution percentages across salary ranges.
Graph depicting the monthly salary distribution for Server jobs in Bay Shore, NY, showing an average salary of $3,322 with varying distribution percentages across salary ranges.
Graph depicting the weekly salary distribution for Server jobs in Bay Shore, NY, showing an average salary of $767 with varying distribution percentages across salary ranges.
Graph depicting the hourly salary distribution for Server jobs in Bay Shore, NY, showing an average salary of $19 with varying distribution percentages across salary ranges.

In Bay Shore, NY, a Server can expect to earn a yearly salary that reflects their dedication and the local economy. The average yearly salary for this role is around $39,869. This figure gives job seekers an idea of what to expect in terms of earnings in this area. Salary figures can vary based on experience, skill level, and the specific restaurant or establishment.

Job seekers should note that the salary for Servers can range quite a bit. Here are some details to consider:

  • About 3.22% of Servers earn less than $21,300 annually.
  • 22.54% of Servers earn between $21,300 and $26,455.
  • More than a third, or 33.81%, earn between $31,609 and $36,764.
  • Another 12.88% fall between $36,764 and $41,918.
  • A smaller group, 3.22%, earn between $72,845 and $78,000 each year.

These numbers show that while entry-level positions start lower, experienced Servers have the opportunity to earn more. This range offers job seekers a realistic view of potential earnings in Bay Shore, NY.

Server jobs in Bay Shore, NY
View all Server jobs in Bay Shore, NY

What are the highest paying cities for a Server near Bay Shore, NY?

Job seekers looking for server roles near Bay Shore, NY, can explore nearby cities with higher average salaries. Hauppauge stands out with the highest average salary at $74,786. Nearby, Babylon offers a competitive $44,384, which is still a strong option for potential earnings. These nearby cities provide ample opportunities for those seeking a rewarding career in server roles.
Graph displaying highest paying cities salaries for Server jobs near Bay Shore, NY, highlighting Hauppauge, NY with the highest at $74,786 and Ronkonkoma, NY with the lowest at $35,000.

  1. Hauppauge, NY
    Average Salary: $74,786
    In Hauppauge, a Server role offers great opportunities with many local eateries and restaurants. Servers here can expect a lively work environment with busy dining rooms and a chance to connect with the community.
    Find Server jobs in Hauppauge, NY


  2. Babylon, NY
    Average Salary: $44,384
    Working as a Server in Babylon provides the chance to serve a diverse crowd. With several popular spots, you can look forward to dynamic shifts and the chance to become a familiar face in the area.
    Find Server jobs in Babylon, NY


  3. North Babylon, NY
    Average Salary: $41,458
    In North Babylon, servers often enjoy a warm atmosphere in family-owned businesses. It’s an excellent place to develop strong relationships with regular customers and enjoy a close-knit community vibe.
    Find Server jobs in North Babylon, NY


  4. Deer Park, NY
    Average Salary: $41,184
    Deer Park offers a mix of casual and upscale dining options for Servers. This area values friendly service, making it a great place to develop strong customer connections.
    Find Server jobs in Deer Park, NY


  5. Dix Hills, NY
    Average Salary: $38,326
    Dix Hills is known for its upscale dining scene, which makes it a prime location for servers seeking tips and a steady flow of guests. It’s a place where attention to detail and customer service can shine.
    Find Server jobs in Dix Hills, NY


  6. Commack, NY
    Average Salary: $36,357
    Commack’s thriving food scene provides many opportunities for servers to grow. Here, you can expect to serve a variety of clientele in a lively, fast-paced environment.
    Find Server jobs in Commack, NY


  7. Patchogue, NY
    Average Salary: $36,132
    Patchogue offers a unique blend of local diners and waterfront restaurants, where servers can enjoy a mix of everyday dining and special occasions. It’s a great area for those who love to interact with a diverse crowd.
    Find Server jobs in Patchogue, NY


  8. Sayville, NY
    Average Salary: $35,492
    Sayville’s dining scene includes everything from cozy cafes to fine dining. Servers in this area will find a welcoming community and a chance to cater to a variety of tastes.
    Find Server jobs in Sayville, NY


  9. Lindenhurst, NY
    Average Salary: $35,129
    Lindenhurst offers a vibrant restaurant culture that values friendly service and community involvement. It’s an ideal place for servers looking to build lasting relationships with guests.
    Find Server jobs in Lindenhurst, NY


  10. Ronkonkoma, NY
    Average Salary: $35,000
    In Ronkonkoma, servers can look forward to working in a range of restaurants that cater to different tastes. It’s a place where attentive service and customer satisfaction are key.
    Find Server jobs in Ronkonkoma, NY

What are the best paying companies for a Server in Bay Shore, NY?

Buffalo Wild Wings, Atria Senior Living, and The Cheesecake Factory offer competitive salaries for server positions in Bay Shore, NY. Buffalo Wild Wings provides an average salary of $43,560, making it a top choice. Atria Senior Living and The Cheesecake Factory also offer solid average salaries of $35,442 and $26,363, respectively. These companies value their servers and offer a chance for professional growth and good earnings.
Graph displaying best paying company salaries for Server jobs in Bay Shore, NY, highlighting Buffalo Wild Wings with the highest at $43,560 and The Cheesecake Factory with the lowest at $26,363.

  1. Buffalo Wild Wings
    Average Salary: $43,560
    Buffalo Wild Wings offers exciting opportunities for Server jobs. This popular sports bar chain serves delicious food and drinks. They have many locations across the country, including Bay Shore, NY. Servers here enjoy a lively atmosphere and the chance to work in a fast-paced environment.


  2. Atria Senior Living
    Average Salary: $35,442
    Atria Senior Living provides fulfilling Server positions. They focus on offering top-notch care and comfort to seniors. With locations in Bay Shore, NY, servers enjoy a friendly work environment. At Atria, servers not only serve food but also create a welcoming space for residents.


  3. The Cheesecake Factory
    Average Salary: $26,363
    The Cheesecake Factory offers diverse Server roles. This well-known restaurant chain features a wide menu with many options. They have locations in Bay Shore, NY, where servers enjoy serving a variety of dishes to guests. The Cheesecake Factory values teamwork and customer service, making it a great place to work.

Currently 14,877 Server job openings, nationwide.

View Server Jobs in Bay Shore, NY

How's the job market for a Server in the US?

Learn what a Server does, how to become one, and understand the job outlook. Get simple steps to start your career as a Server today.
Position
Overview
Server
14,877 Job Openings

Win at hiring.

Visit the help center for any questions.
Contact Support
ReadySetHire icon
©2025 • ReadySetHire