Server Salary in Garden City, NY

Updated on May 09, 2025
Position
City
Salary

How much does a Server make in Garden City, NY?

The average salary for a Server is $35,848 per year in Garden City, NY.

A server in Garden City, NY, can expect to earn a competitive salary. On average, servers make around $35,848 per year. This figure can vary based on experience, the type of establishment, and other factors. Many servers also earn tips, which can add significantly to their income.

The salary range for servers in Garden City, NY, typically spans from $20,000 to $75,000 annually. The most common salary range falls between $30,000 and $40,000. Servers with more experience or those working in high-end restaurants often earn more. Some servers also receive benefits such as health insurance, paid time off, and retirement plans, which can enhance their overall compensation package.

Server jobs in Garden City, NY

What are the highest paying cities for a Server near Garden City, NY?

Job seekers looking for server positions near Garden City, NY, can find some of the highest paying opportunities in Bellmore, NY. The average salary for servers in Bellmore is $44,418, offering a competitive edge. Other nearby cities like Long Beach and Hempstead also provide attractive salaries, making them good options for those in the field.
Graph displaying highest paying cities salaries for Server jobs near Garden City, NY, highlighting Bellmore, NY with the highest at $44,418 and East Meadow, NY with the lowest at $30,117.
  1. Bellmore, NY
    Average Salary: $44,418
    In Bellmore, NY, working as a server offers a dynamic environment with many dining options. Servers here often work in family-owned restaurants and cafes. The hospitality industry thrives, providing ample opportunities for growth.
    Find Server jobs in Bellmore, NY


  2. Long Beach, NY
    Average Salary: $40,250
    Long Beach, NY, is known for its vibrant dining scene. Servers here enjoy a lively atmosphere with many tourists and locals. Working in this area means being part of a bustling community with diverse culinary offerings.
    Find Server jobs in Long Beach, NY


  3. Hempstead, NY
    Average Salary: $39,414
    Hempstead, NY, provides a mix of casual and fine dining options for servers. The area is home to a variety of restaurants, including popular chains and local eateries. Servers here can expect a steady flow of customers and a chance to work in a diverse food environment.
    Find Server jobs in Hempstead, NY


  4. Lynbrook, NY
    Average Salary: $35,891
    Lynbrook, NY, offers a cozy dining experience with many family-friendly restaurants. Servers in this area often enjoy a close-knit community feel. The area's dining scene is perfect for those who value a welcoming and friendly work environment.
    Find Server jobs in Lynbrook, NY


  5. Elmont, NY
    Average Salary: $32,377
    Elmont, NY, has a growing dining scene with many new restaurants. Servers here can expect a fast-paced environment with opportunities for learning and growth. The area is ideal for those looking to gain experience in a dynamic setting.
    Find Server jobs in Elmont, NY


  6. Rockville Centre, NY
    Average Salary: $31,959
    Rockville Centre, NY, is known for its upscale dining options. Servers in this area often work in fine dining establishments. The area offers a chance to work in a sophisticated environment with a focus on high-quality service.
    Find Server jobs in Rockville Centre, NY


  7. Carle Place, NY
    Average Salary: $30,983
    Carle Place, NY, provides a mix of casual and fine dining experiences. Servers here often work in a variety of restaurants, from local favorites to more upscale venues. The area offers a diverse work environment with plenty of opportunities.
    Find Server jobs in Carle Place, NY


  8. Westbury, NY
    Average Salary: $30,569
    Westbury, NY, is home to many upscale dining establishments. Servers here can expect to work in a refined environment with a focus on excellent service. The area offers a chance to work in a prestigious setting with a diverse clientele.
    Find Server jobs in Westbury, NY


  9. Valley Stream, NY
    Average Salary: $30,489
    Valley Stream, NY, offers a variety of dining options, from casual cafes to fine dining restaurants. Servers in this area can expect a diverse work environment with plenty of opportunities. The area is ideal for those looking to gain experience in different types of restaurants.
    Find Server jobs in Valley Stream, NY


  10. East Meadow, NY
    Average Salary: $30,117
    East Meadow, NY, provides a mix of dining options, including family-owned restaurants and cafes. Servers here often enjoy a friendly and welcoming atmosphere. The area offers a chance to work in a community-focused environment with many opportunities for growth.
    Find Server jobs in East Meadow, NY

What are the best paying companies for a Server in Garden City, NY?

Garden City, NY, offers several top-paying companies for server jobs. Maggiano's Little Italy leads with an average annual salary of $89,167. True Food Kitchen and The Bristal Assisted Living also provide competitive salaries, with averages of $41,041 and $37,342, respectively. These companies value their servers and offer attractive compensation packages.
Graph displaying best paying company salaries for Server jobs in Garden City, NY, highlighting Maggiano's Little Italy with the highest at $89,167 and Small Batch with the lowest at $31,167.
  1. Maggiano's Little Italy
    Average Salary: $89,167
    Maggiano's Little Italy offers a warm, family-friendly atmosphere. They serve classic Italian dishes. This company operates in many locations across the United States.


  2. True Food Kitchen
    Average Salary: $41,041
    True Food Kitchen focuses on healthy, delicious meals. They use fresh ingredients and offer a variety of dishes. This company has locations in many cities across the country.


  3. The Bristal Assisted Living
    Average Salary: $37,342
    The Bristal Assisted Living provides care for seniors. They offer a range of services to support residents. The company operates in several locations, including Garden City, NY.


  4. Bloomingdale's
    Average Salary: $36,963
    Bloomingdale's is a luxury department store. They offer a wide range of products, including clothing and home goods. The store is located in Garden City, NY.


  5. Shake Shack
    Average Salary: $35,805
    Shake Shack is known for its burgers and shakes. They offer a casual dining experience. This company has locations in many cities, including Garden City, NY.


  6. The Garden City Hotel
    Average Salary: $34,550
    The Garden City Hotel provides comfortable accommodations. They offer a range of services to guests. The hotel is located in Garden City, NY.


  7. Altamarea Group
    Average Salary: $33,150
    Altamarea Group operates several restaurants. They focus on providing quality food and service. The company has locations in many cities, including Garden City, NY.


  8. Buffalo Wild Wings
    Average Salary: $32,390
    Buffalo Wild Wings is a sports bar and restaurant. They offer a variety of food and drinks. This company has locations in many cities, including Garden City, NY.


  9. Van Leeuwen Ice Cream LLC
    Average Salary: $32,333
    Van Leeuwen Ice Cream LLC makes artisanal ice cream. They offer a range of flavors and toppings. The company has locations in many cities, including Garden City, NY.


  10. Small Batch
    Average Salary: $31,167
    Small Batch focuses on creating unique and delicious food. They offer a variety of dishes. This company has locations in many cities, including Garden City, NY.

Currently 24,699 Server job openings, nationwide.

How's the job market for a Server in the US?

Learn what a Server does, how to become one, and understand the job outlook. Get simple steps to start your career as a Server today.
Position
Overview
Server
24,699 Job Openings