Server Server Salary in Garden City, NY

Server Salary in Garden City, NY

Updated on Mar 10, 2026
Position
City
Salary

How much does a Server make in Garden City, NY?

The average salary for a Server is $33,581 per year in Garden City, NY.
Yearly
Monthly
Weekly
Hourly
Graph depicting the yearly salary distribution for Server jobs in Garden City, NY, showing an average salary of $33,581 with varying distribution percentages across salary ranges.
Graph depicting the monthly salary distribution for Server jobs in Garden City, NY, showing an average salary of $2,798 with varying distribution percentages across salary ranges.
Graph depicting the weekly salary distribution for Server jobs in Garden City, NY, showing an average salary of $646 with varying distribution percentages across salary ranges.
Graph depicting the hourly salary distribution for Server jobs in Garden City, NY, showing an average salary of $16 with varying distribution percentages across salary ranges.

Servers in Garden City, NY, earn a competitive salary. The average yearly salary is about $33,581. This amount can vary based on experience and the type of restaurant. Those who work at busy, popular restaurants often earn more.


The salary range for servers in this area shows a spread from about $20,000 to over $90,000. Most servers fall between the mid-to-upper range, which is around $32,727 to $64,545. This range reflects the income of those who work consistently and build good rapport with customers. Servers who take on additional roles, such as managing shifts or overseeing events, can also see their earnings increase.

Server jobs in Garden City, NY
View all Server jobs in Garden City, NY

What are the highest paying cities for a Server near Garden City, NY?

Job seekers in the Garden City area have strong opportunities for server jobs with competitive salaries. Uniondale tops the list, offering the highest average salary of $51,452. Nearby, Bellmore and Elmont also provide attractive salary packages, making them good choices for aspiring servers. Being close to Garden City, these cities ensure that servers can enjoy both high earnings and a convenient commute.
Graph displaying highest paying cities salaries for Server jobs near Garden City, NY, highlighting Uniondale, NY with the highest at $51,452 and Westbury, NY with the lowest at $31,533.

  1. Uniondale, NY
    Average Salary: $51,452
    Uniondale offers a dynamic environment for those looking to work in hospitality. With several upscale restaurants and bars, job seekers can find opportunities that range from casual dining to fine dining. Local businesses like Margaritas and East Wind provide a chance to grow in a vibrant food scene.
    Find Server jobs in Uniondale, NY


  2. Bellmore, NY
    Average Salary: $47,366
    In Bellmore, servers have the chance to work in a diverse range of eateries. From family-owned diners to trendy cafes, this city offers a variety of environments. Companies like The Applebee’s and The Oceanaire offer excellent opportunities for those who thrive in a bustling atmosphere.
    Find Server jobs in Bellmore, NY


  3. Elmont, NY
    Average Salary: $41,675
    Elmont presents a mix of family restaurants and larger chain establishments. Servers here enjoy a community feel while working in a growing hospitality sector. Local spots like Johnny Rockets and TGI Fridays provide dynamic and engaging work settings.
    Find Server jobs in Elmont, NY


  4. Hempstead, NY
    Average Salary: $38,584
    Hempstead boasts a lively food culture with many diverse dining options. Servers here can expect to interact with a variety of customers while working in establishments such as Applebee’s and Red Lobster. The area’s hospitality needs offer steady and rewarding job prospects.
    Find Server jobs in Hempstead, NY


  5. Long Beach, NY
    Average Salary: $37,667
    Long Beach is known for its vibrant beach culture and bustling restaurants. Servers here enjoy a lively atmosphere and often have the chance to work in waterfront dining. Restaurants such as Tony’s and The Lobster Place offer exciting opportunities for those in the hospitality field.
    Find Server jobs in Long Beach, NY


  6. Lynbrook, NY
    Average Salary: $37,228
    Lynbrook offers a blend of cozy cafes and family-friendly restaurants. Servers in this area can expect to work in a welcoming environment while gaining valuable experience. Local favorites like The Olive Garden and Red Lobster provide solid opportunities for growth.
    Find Server jobs in Lynbrook, NY


  7. East Meadow, NY
    Average Salary: $33,593
    East Meadow provides a mix of casual and fine dining options. Servers here can find positions in both local eateries and larger establishments. Companies like Buffalo Wild Wings and Chili’s offer diverse experiences and a chance to develop strong customer service skills.
    Find Server jobs in East Meadow, NY


  8. Rockville Centre, NY
    Average Salary: $32,264
    Rockville Centre is home to a variety of restaurants, from casual diners to upscale venues. Servers here can expect to work in a professional environment with many opportunities for career advancement. Local businesses like P.F. Chang’s and Red Lobster provide excellent platforms for hospitality careers.
    Find Server jobs in Rockville Centre, NY


  9. Mineola, NY
    Average Salary: $31,844
    Mineola offers a mix of classic diners and trendy restaurants. Servers in this area can enjoy a diverse work environment while gaining experience in a thriving hospitality sector. Local establishments like The Cheesecake Factory and Chili’s offer rewarding career opportunities.
    Find Server jobs in Mineola, NY


  10. Westbury, NY
    Average Salary: $31,533
    Westbury is known for its vibrant food scene and diverse dining options. Servers here can expect to work in an engaging environment with many opportunities for growth. Local restaurants like Chili’s and Applebee’s provide excellent settings for those entering the hospitality field.
    Find Server jobs in Westbury, NY

What are the best paying companies for a Server in Garden City, NY?

Maggiano's Little Italy offers a top-paying job for servers in Garden City, NY, with an average salary of $92,000. This company values its employees and provides a great opportunity for growth. True Food Kitchen and The Bristal Assisted Living also offer competitive wages, with averages around $37,000. Servers can find good pay with Chartwells Higher Education, Shake Shack, and Kings, all offering salaries over $32,000. These companies provide a chance to earn a steady income while working in a dynamic environment.
Graph displaying best paying company salaries for Server jobs in Garden City, NY, highlighting Maggiano's Little Italy with the highest at $92,000 and Grand Lux Cafe with the lowest at $24,523.

  1. Maggiano's Little Italy
    Average Salary: $92,000
    Maggiano's Little Italy is a family-style Italian restaurant with locations in many shopping malls. The company provides its servers with opportunities for growth and a chance to provide high-quality service. The Garden City location is part of the Roosevelt Field Mall.


  2. True Food Kitchen
    Average Salary: $37,680
    True Food Kitchen offers healthy, organic meals made with local ingredients. They serve a variety of dishes from breakfast to dinner. Their Garden City location is a popular spot for those looking for fresh and nutritious food options.


  3. The Bristal Assisted Living
    Average Salary: $37,336
    The Bristal is an assisted living facility that provides a range of services for elderly residents. Servers here work in the dining services department, ensuring that residents enjoy their meals. This company emphasizes care and hospitality, with locations throughout the New York area.


  4. Chartwells Higher Education
    Average Salary: $35,625
    Chartwells Higher Education provides dining services for students and faculty. Servers here work in a fast-paced environment but focus on providing a high level of customer service. This company has multiple locations in and around Garden City.


  5. Shake Shack
    Average Salary: $34,589
    Shake Shack is a popular burger joint known for its high-quality food and fun atmosphere. Servers work in a dynamic environment, serving a wide range of customers. Garden City is home to one of their locations.


  6. Kings
    Average Salary: $32,667
    Kings is a modern American restaurant with a focus on craft cocktails and innovative dishes. Servers here need to be knowledgeable about the menu and able to recommend dishes to guests. The Garden City location is part of the Roosevelt Field Mall.


  7. Buffalo Wild Wings
    Average Salary: $32,390
    Buffalo Wild Wings is a sports bar known for its wings and casual atmosphere. Servers here serve a variety of food and drinks to customers. Garden City has one of their locations, which is popular among sports fans.


  8. Van Leeuwen Ice Cream LLC
    Average Salary: $32,333
    Van Leeuwen Ice Cream is an artisan ice cream shop with locations in many areas. Servers here focus on serving high-quality ice cream and other treats. Garden City is home to one of their locations.


  9. Small Batch
    Average Salary: $32,000
    Small Batch is a restaurant and bar that offers a menu of small plates and a variety of craft cocktails. Servers here work in a trendy environment and need to be friendly and knowledgeable. The Garden City location is part of the Roosevelt Field Mall.


  10. Grand Lux Cafe
    Average Salary: $24,523
    Grand Lux Cafe is a casual dining spot known for its creative menu and relaxed atmosphere. Servers here work in a vibrant environment and focus on providing excellent service. Garden City is home to one of their locations.

Currently 18,672 Server job openings, nationwide.

View Server Jobs in Garden City, NY

How's the job market for a Server in the US?

Learn what a Server does, how to become one, and understand the job outlook. Get simple steps to start your career as a Server today.
Position
Overview
Server
18,672 Job Openings

Win at hiring.

Visit the help center for any questions.
Contact Support
ReadySetHire icon
©2025 • ReadySetHire