Server Server Salary in Garden City, NY

Server Salary in Garden City, NY

Updated on Jun 10, 2026
Position
City
Salary

How much does a Server make in Garden City, NY?

The average salary for a Server is $31,961 per year in Garden City, NY.
Yearly
Monthly
Weekly
Hourly
Graph depicting the yearly salary distribution for Server jobs in Garden City, NY, showing an average salary of $31,961 with varying distribution percentages across salary ranges.
Graph depicting the monthly salary distribution for Server jobs in Garden City, NY, showing an average salary of $2,663 with varying distribution percentages across salary ranges.
Graph depicting the weekly salary distribution for Server jobs in Garden City, NY, showing an average salary of $615 with varying distribution percentages across salary ranges.
Graph depicting the hourly salary distribution for Server jobs in Garden City, NY, showing an average salary of $15 with varying distribution percentages across salary ranges.

In Garden City, NY, servers can expect to earn a yearly salary that varies based on their experience and specific skills. Most servers start with an entry-level salary around $24,000. With a few years of experience, they can increase their earnings up to $32,000. Seasoned and skilled servers may earn more, with some reaching up to $40,000 annually.

The average yearly salary for a server in Garden City, NY, is around $31,961. This average helps job seekers understand what to expect as they gain experience. Factors such as working in busy restaurants or during peak hours can also lead to higher tips and bonuses, improving overall earnings.

Server jobs in Garden City, NY
View all Server jobs in Garden City, NY

What are the highest paying cities for a Server near Garden City, NY?

Looking for a lucrative Server job near Garden City, NY? Consider Uniondale, NY, where the average salary is $51,452. Nearby, Bellmore, NY, offers an average salary of $49,961, making it a strong contender for job seekers. Elmont, NY, also presents good opportunities with an average salary of $39,223. These cities near Garden City, NY, provide competitive salaries for Server positions. For those willing to explore nearby locations, there are promising options to enhance career prospects. Salaries in these areas reflect the demand for skilled Server professionals.
Graph displaying highest paying cities salaries for Server jobs near Garden City, NY, highlighting Uniondale, NY with the highest at $51,452 and Mineola, NY with the lowest at $33,276.

  1. Uniondale, NY
    Average Salary: $51,452
    In Uniondale, you can find a range of restaurants and eateries that offer exciting opportunities. With many local chains and popular eateries, you can gain valuable experience in a vibrant dining scene. Companies like the Nassau Veterans Memorial Coliseum provide unique environments.
    Find Server jobs in Uniondale, NY


  2. Bellmore, NY
    Average Salary: $49,961
    Bellmore has a strong dining culture with many local favorites. Working as a server here means you will interact with a diverse range of customers. Opportunities exist in family-owned businesses and larger chain restaurants.
    Find Server jobs in Bellmore, NY


  3. Elmont, NY
    Average Salary: $39,223
    Elmont is home to several hospitality businesses, offering a variety of settings for server positions. This area is known for its mix of casual diners and upscale dining. Companies like the Belmont Park Racetrack provide dynamic work environments.
    Find Server jobs in Elmont, NY


  4. Lynbrook, NY
    Average Salary: $37,113
    Lynbrook offers a mix of cozy cafes and elegant restaurants. This area values friendly service and attention to detail. Servers here often find work in both independent and chain establishments.
    Find Server jobs in Lynbrook, NY


  5. Hempstead, NY
    Average Salary: $36,639
    Hempstead has a bustling dining scene with many local and chain restaurants. Working here allows for a chance to work in diverse settings, from casual diners to fine dining establishments. Companies like the Nassau County Center provide unique work environments.
    Find Server jobs in Hempstead, NY


  6. Long Beach, NY
    Average Salary: $36,261
    Long Beach is known for its vibrant beachfront dining. Servers here enjoy a lively atmosphere and a chance to work in both casual and upscale settings. The city's focus on hospitality creates a welcoming environment for newcomers.
    Find Server jobs in Long Beach, NY


  7. East Meadow, NY
    Average Salary: $34,748
    East Meadow offers a variety of dining options, from family-friendly restaurants to elegant bistros. Servers in this area often find work in both casual and formal settings, with a focus on excellent customer service.
    Find Server jobs in East Meadow, NY


  8. Westbury, NY
    Average Salary: $34,644
    Westbury features a mix of local favorites and well-known chains. The dining scene here values professional service and attention to detail. Servers can find opportunities in a variety of settings, from cozy cafes to fine dining restaurants.
    Find Server jobs in Westbury, NY


  9. Farmingdale, NY
    Average Salary: $34,515
    Farmingdale has a diverse dining scene with many local eateries and chain restaurants. Working here means you can gain experience in a range of environments. The area values friendly service and a warm atmosphere.
    Find Server jobs in Farmingdale, NY


  10. Mineola, NY
    Average Salary: $33,276
    Mineola offers a vibrant dining scene with a mix of independent and chain restaurants. Servers here often find work in both casual and upscale settings. The city's focus on hospitality creates a welcoming environment for newcomers.
    Find Server jobs in Mineola, NY

What are the best paying companies for a Server in Garden City, NY?

Maggiano’s Little Italy offers high salaries for server positions in Garden City, NY, with an average of $92,500 per year. This competitive pay makes it a top choice for job seekers. Additionally, The Bristal Assisted Living provides a solid average salary of $37,570, making it another excellent option.
Graph displaying best paying company salaries for Server jobs in Garden City, NY, highlighting Maggiano's Little Italy with the highest at $92,500 and Grand Lux Cafe with the lowest at $25,348.

  1. Maggiano's Little Italy
    Average Salary: $92,500
    Maggiano's Little Italy offers excellent Server jobs in Garden City, NY. The company provides a warm and welcoming environment, emphasizing excellent customer service. Maggiano's is a part of the larger Darden Restaurant group, with locations across the United States.


  2. The Bristal Assisted Living
    Average Salary: $37,570
    The Bristal Assisted Living offers competitive Server jobs in Garden City, NY. This company focuses on providing quality care in a warm setting. The Bristal operates residential care facilities that serve the senior community, primarily in the Northeastern United States.


  3. Chartwells Higher Education
    Average Salary: $35,917
    Chartwells Higher Education provides rewarding Server positions in Garden City, NY. This company manages dining services for educational institutions. Chartwells Higher Education operates on campuses across the country, serving students and staff with a range of dining options.


  4. Shake Shack
    Average Salary: $34,060
    Shake Shack offers attractive Server jobs in Garden City, NY. This company prides itself on its fast-casual dining experience. With locations nationwide, Shake Shack is known for its burgers and shakes, offering a fun and engaging work environment.


  5. Kings
    Average Salary: $32,800
    Kings provides good Server jobs in Garden City, NY. This company is known for its casual dining with a focus on comfort food. Kings operates multiple locations across the United States, offering a vibrant and welcoming atmosphere for both staff and customers.


  6. Buffalo Wild Wings
    Average Salary: $32,390
    Buffalo Wild Wings offers rewarding Server positions in Garden City, NY. This company is famous for its sports bar atmosphere and wide selection of wings and beers. Buffalo Wild Wings has numerous locations across the country, creating a fun and energetic work environment.


  7. Small Batch
    Average Salary: $32,333
    Small Batch provides competitive Server jobs in Garden City, NY. The company focuses on crafting delicious and locally-sourced meals. Small Batch operates several locations, emphasizing a rustic and inviting dining experience.


  8. True Food Kitchen
    Average Salary: $28,533
    True Food Kitchen offers fulfilling Server jobs in Garden City, NY. This company emphasizes healthy, whole foods and a welcoming dining experience. True Food Kitchen has multiple locations, known for its farm-to-table philosophy and vibrant atmosphere.


  9. The Garden City Hotel
    Average Salary: $26,533
    The Garden City Hotel provides valuable Server positions in Garden City, NY. This hotel offers a dynamic work environment with opportunities to serve a diverse clientele. The Garden City Hotel is part of a larger hotel chain, with locations across the United States.


  10. Grand Lux Cafe
    Average Salary: $25,348
    Grand Lux Cafe offers good Server jobs in Garden City, NY. This cafe is known for its eclectic menu and vibrant atmosphere. With locations in various cities, Grand Lux Cafe provides a fun and lively place to work.

Currently 14,877 Server job openings, nationwide.

View Server Jobs in Garden City, NY

How's the job market for a Server in the US?

Learn what a Server does, how to become one, and understand the job outlook. Get simple steps to start your career as a Server today.
Position
Overview
Server
14,877 Job Openings

Win at hiring.

Visit the help center for any questions.
Contact Support
ReadySetHire icon
©2025 • ReadySetHire