Server Salary in Smithtown, NY

Updated on May 09, 2025
Position
City
Salary

How much does a Server make in Smithtown, NY?

The average salary for a Server is $35,766 per year in Smithtown, NY.

In Smithtown, NY, servers can expect to earn a competitive salary. The average annual salary for a server in this area is around $35,766. This figure can vary based on experience, the type of restaurant, and the specific location within Smithtown. Servers often have the opportunity to earn additional income through tips, which can significantly boost their earnings.

Factors that influence a server's salary include the time of year, the popularity of the restaurant, and the server's ability to manage a busy schedule. Servers who work in high-end restaurants or during peak seasons can earn more than the average. Additionally, those who excel in customer service and have strong communication skills may receive higher tips, further enhancing their earnings.

Server jobs in Smithtown, NY

What are the highest paying cities for a Server near Smithtown, NY?

Job seekers looking for server positions near Smithtown, NY, can find competitive salaries in nearby cities. Mount Sinai, NY, offers the highest pay, with an average salary of $70,743. This makes it a prime location for those seeking better compensation. Other nearby cities like Hauppauge and Babylon also provide good opportunities with salaries around $64,812 and $41,884, respectively.
Graph displaying highest paying cities salaries for Server jobs near Smithtown, NY, highlighting Mount Sinai, NY with the highest at $70,743 and Sayville, NY with the lowest at $31,654.
  1. Mount Sinai, NY
    Average Salary: $70,743
    In Mount Sinai, working as a server offers a chance to serve guests in a charming, community-focused environment. With a variety of local eateries, servers can enjoy a welcoming atmosphere. Opportunities exist in both casual and fine dining settings.
    Find Server jobs in Mount Sinai, NY


  2. Hauppauge, NY
    Average Salary: $64,812
    Hauppauge provides a vibrant setting for servers, with many restaurants and cafes seeking skilled staff. Servers here can expect to work in a dynamic environment, serving a diverse clientele. The area's growing popularity makes it a great place for career growth.
    Find Server jobs in Hauppauge, NY


  3. Bradley Beach, NJ
    Average Salary: $44,944
    Bradley Beach offers a lively beachside atmosphere for servers, with many restaurants and bars looking for energetic staff. Servers can enjoy the coastal charm while serving guests. The seasonal influx of tourists provides varied opportunities throughout the year.
    Find Server jobs in Bradley Beach, NJ


  4. Babylon, NY
    Average Salary: $41,884
    Babylon presents a bustling environment for servers, with a mix of family-owned restaurants and larger establishments. Servers here can expect a steady flow of customers, offering a variety of dining experiences. The area's diverse population adds to the dynamic work environment.
    Find Server jobs in Babylon, NY


  5. Northport, NY
    Average Salary: $36,866
    In Northport, servers can enjoy a quaint, historic setting with a variety of dining options. The town's charm attracts a steady stream of visitors, providing ample opportunities for servers. Working here means serving in a picturesque and friendly environment.
    Find Server jobs in Northport, NY


  6. Lake Grove, NY
    Average Salary: $34,381
    Lake Grove offers a peaceful setting for servers, with many local restaurants and cafes. Servers here can enjoy a relaxed atmosphere, serving a loyal customer base. The town's community-focused environment makes it a great place to work.
    Find Server jobs in Lake Grove, NY


  7. Commack, NY
    Average Salary: $34,166
    Commack provides a welcoming environment for servers, with a range of dining options from casual to upscale. Servers here can expect to serve a diverse clientele, enjoying the town's friendly atmosphere. The area's growth offers opportunities for career advancement.
    Find Server jobs in Commack, NY


  8. Patchogue, NY
    Average Salary: $33,840
    Patchogue offers a vibrant setting for servers, with many restaurants and bars along the waterfront. Servers here can enjoy a dynamic work environment, serving a mix of locals and tourists. The town's lively atmosphere provides varied opportunities for growth.
    Find Server jobs in Patchogue, NY


  9. Lindenhurst, NY
    Average Salary: $32,629
    In Lindenhurst, servers can enjoy a bustling environment with a variety of dining options. The town's diverse population offers a rich culinary experience, making it an exciting place to work. Servers here can expect a steady flow of customers and a welcoming community.
    Find Server jobs in Lindenhurst, NY


  10. Sayville, NY
    Average Salary: $31,654
    Sayville provides a charming setting for servers, with many local restaurants and cafes. Servers here can enjoy a friendly atmosphere, serving a loyal customer base. The town's historic charm adds to the unique dining experience.
    Find Server jobs in Sayville, NY

What are the best paying companies for a Server in Smithtown, NY?

Job seekers looking for server positions in Smithtown, NY, have several good options. The Fresh Market offers a competitive salary of $39,104. Sunrise Senior Living provides a solid $35,760, while Carrabba's Italian Grill pays $33,725. Benchmark Senior Living and Taco Bell also offer attractive salaries, making them viable choices for those seeking good pay. Each of these companies provides a stable environment with opportunities for growth. The Fresh Market and Sunrise Senior Living, in particular, offer benefits that can enhance job satisfaction. Carrabba's Italian Grill, Benchmark Senior Living, and Taco Bell also provide a good work-life balance, making them excellent places to work.
Graph displaying best paying company salaries for Server jobs in Smithtown, NY, highlighting The Fresh Market with the highest at $39,104 and Taco Bell with the lowest at $29,000.
  1. The Fresh Market
    Average Salary: $39,104
    The Fresh Market offers a dynamic work environment for server jobs. Employees serve fresh food and beverages to customers. The company operates multiple locations in Smithtown, NY, providing ample opportunities for growth and experience.


  2. Sunrise Senior Living
    Average Salary: $35,760
    Sunrise Senior Living provides rewarding server positions. Servers work in dining areas, ensuring residents and guests have a pleasant dining experience. The company runs several facilities in Smithtown, NY, offering a stable and supportive work environment.


  3. Carrabba's Italian Grill
    Average Salary: $33,725
    Carrabba's Italian Grill is known for its vibrant atmosphere and excellent service. Servers at Carrabba's are responsible for delivering top-notch customer service and serving delicious Italian dishes. The restaurant is located in Smithtown, NY, providing a lively setting for servers.


  4. Benchmark Senior Living
    Average Salary: $33,250
    Benchmark Senior Living offers server positions that focus on providing excellent service to residents and guests. Servers ensure a warm and welcoming dining experience. The company operates multiple locations in Smithtown, NY, offering a chance to work in a caring and supportive environment.


  5. Taco Bell
    Average Salary: $29,000
    Taco Bell provides a fast-paced environment for server jobs. Servers are responsible for serving quick and tasty Mexican-inspired food. The restaurant is located in Smithtown, NY, offering a fun and energetic workplace for servers.

Currently 24,699 Server job openings, nationwide.

How's the job market for a Server in the US?

Learn what a Server does, how to become one, and understand the job outlook. Get simple steps to start your career as a Server today.
Position
Overview
Server
24,699 Job Openings