Shift Manager Salary in Mentor, OH

Updated on May 09, 2025
Position
City
Salary

How much does a Shift Manager make in Mentor, OH?

The average salary for a Shift Manager is $51,631 per year in Mentor, OH.

A Shift Manager in Mentor, OH, earns an average salary of around $51,631. This figure represents a good earning potential for those in this role. The salary range can vary from about $35,000 to $60,000, depending on experience and other factors.

Factors that can influence a Shift Manager's salary include the size of the company, the industry, and the specific responsibilities of the role. Those with more experience or additional skills may earn more. Shift Managers often oversee a team, manage schedules, and ensure smooth operations during their shift. This role requires strong leadership and communication skills, which can also impact salary levels.

Shift Manager jobs in Mentor, OH

What are the highest paying cities for a Shift Manager near Mentor, OH?

Job seekers looking for Shift Manager roles near Mentor, OH, can find attractive opportunities in nearby cities. North Olmsted, OH, offers the highest average salary at $52,233. Strongsville, OH, follows closely with an average salary of $52,167. These cities provide competitive pay and a chance to advance in a rewarding career.
Graph displaying highest paying cities salaries for Shift Manager jobs near Mentor, OH, highlighting North Olmsted, OH with the highest at $52,233 and Lakewood, OH with the lowest at $38,125.
  1. North Olmsted, OH
    Average Salary: $52,233
    In North Olmsted, overseeing a team in a retail setting offers a dynamic work environment. With companies like Meijer and local businesses, you'll manage daily operations and ensure customer satisfaction. The community's support for local enterprises makes it a rewarding place to lead a team.
    Find Shift Manager jobs in North Olmsted, OH


  2. Strongsville, OH
    Average Salary: $52,167
    Strongsville provides a vibrant atmosphere for those managing shifts in various industries. Working with companies like Walmart and local restaurants, you'll coordinate staff and maintain high service standards. The city's growing business scene offers many opportunities for career growth.
    Find Shift Manager jobs in Strongsville, OH


  3. Willoughby, OH
    Average Salary: $50,261
    Willoughby is a great place to lead a team in a quieter, yet thriving community. With businesses such as Topgolf and local cafes, you'll manage operations and foster a positive work environment. The city's family-friendly atmosphere makes it a pleasant place to work.
    Find Shift Manager jobs in Willoughby, OH


  4. Cleveland, OH
    Average Salary: $48,601
    In Cleveland, managing a shift means being part of a bustling urban environment. Working with major companies like Progressive and local eateries, you'll handle daily tasks and ensure smooth operations. The city's diverse business landscape offers many chances for professional development.
    Find Shift Manager jobs in Cleveland, OH


  5. Brunswick, OH
    Average Salary: $42,692
    Brunswick offers a close-knit community where managing shifts can be very fulfilling. With local businesses and companies like FirstEnergy, you'll oversee staff and ensure excellent service. The city's supportive environment makes it a great place to lead a team.
    Find Shift Manager jobs in Brunswick, OH


  6. Rocky River, OH
    Average Salary: $40,833
    Rocky River provides a serene setting for those managing shifts in various industries. Working with local businesses and companies like KeyBank, you'll coordinate staff and maintain high standards. The city's peaceful atmosphere makes it a pleasant place to work.
    Find Shift Manager jobs in Rocky River, OH


  7. Lakewood, OH
    Average Salary: $38,125
    In Lakewood, overseeing a team means being part of a diverse and growing community. Working with companies like Sherwin-Williams and local restaurants, you'll manage operations and ensure customer satisfaction. The city's vibrant business scene offers many opportunities for career growth.
    Find Shift Manager jobs in Lakewood, OH

What are the best paying companies for a Shift Manager in Mentor, OH?

Conrad's Tire Express and Total Car Care offers one of the highest salaries for Shift Manager positions in Mentor, OH. With an average salary of $54,112, this company provides a competitive pay package. Blue Falls Car Wash and Orangetheory Fitness also offer attractive salaries, with averages of $43,500 and $42,533, respectively. These companies value their shift managers and recognize the importance of fair compensation. Job seekers can expect good pay and benefits when applying for these roles.
Graph displaying best paying company salaries for Shift Manager jobs in Mentor, OH, highlighting Conrad's Tire Express and Total Car Care with the highest at $54,112 and Orangetheory Fitness with the lowest at $42,533.
  1. Conrad's Tire Express and Total Car Care
    Average Salary: $54,112
    Conrad's Tire Express and Total Car Care offers Shift Manager jobs with a focus on customer service and team leadership. This company operates multiple locations in Mentor, OH, providing a stable work environment. Shift Managers here manage daily operations, ensuring smooth service delivery and customer satisfaction.


  2. Blue Falls Car Wash
    Average Salary: $43,500
    Blue Falls Car Wash provides Shift Manager positions that emphasize operational efficiency and team management. The company has several locations in Mentor, OH, where Shift Managers oversee staff, maintain cleanliness, and ensure customer satisfaction. This role is ideal for those who enjoy a dynamic work environment.


  3. Orangetheory Fitness
    Average Salary: $42,533
    Orangetheory Fitness offers Shift Manager jobs that focus on fitness and team leadership. This company operates multiple studios in Mentor, OH, where Shift Managers lead workout sessions, manage staff, and ensure a motivating atmosphere. This role is perfect for fitness enthusiasts who want to combine their passion with management responsibilities.

Currently 689 Shift Manager job openings, nationwide.

How's the job market for a Shift Manager in the US?

Learn what a Shift Manager does, how to become one, and understand the job outlook. Get simple steps to start your career as a Shift Manager today.
Position
Overview
Shift Manager
689 Job Openings