Substitute Teacher Substitute Teacher Salary in Appleton, WI

Substitute Teacher Salary in Appleton, WI

Updated on Jun 10, 2026
Position
City
Salary

How much does a Substitute Teacher make in Appleton, WI?

The average salary for a Substitute Teacher is $33,839 per year in Appleton, WI.
Yearly
Monthly
Weekly
Hourly
Graph depicting the yearly salary distribution for Substitute Teacher jobs in Appleton, WI, showing an average salary of $33,839 with varying distribution percentages across salary ranges.
Graph depicting the monthly salary distribution for Substitute Teacher jobs in Appleton, WI, showing an average salary of $2,820 with varying distribution percentages across salary ranges.
Graph depicting the weekly salary distribution for Substitute Teacher jobs in Appleton, WI, showing an average salary of $651 with varying distribution percentages across salary ranges.
Graph depicting the hourly salary distribution for Substitute Teacher jobs in Appleton, WI, showing an average salary of $16 with varying distribution percentages across salary ranges.

Substitute teachers in Appleton, Wisconsin, generally earn an average yearly salary of $33,839. This figure provides a good benchmark for those considering a career in this role. The range of salaries can vary depending on several factors, including experience and qualifications.

To understand the salary distribution, consider these key points:

  • About 41.56% of substitute teachers earn between $31,000 and $33,775 per year.
  • Another 11.88% earn between $33,775 and $36,549 annually.
  • The highest 11.88% earn more than $36,549 each year.

Substitute Teacher jobs in Appleton, WI
View all Substitute Teacher jobs in Appleton, WI

What are the highest paying cities for a Substitute Teacher near Appleton, WI?

Substitute Teacher jobs in nearby cities offer competitive pay, with Beloit, WI, leading the pack. The average salary in Beloit is about $61,218. This is the highest among nearby cities like Oshkosh, WI, and Plymouth, WI. Job seekers in Appleton, WI, can find attractive opportunities for Substitute Teachers in these neighboring cities. Oshkosh, WI, and Plymouth, WI, also provide solid average salaries, making them good options. Green Bay, WI, and the rest of the listed cities are reliable choices for those seeking stable incomes.
Graph displaying highest paying cities salaries for Substitute Teacher jobs near Appleton, WI, highlighting Beloit, WI with the highest at $61,218 and Waupaca, WI with the lowest at $31,000.

  1. Beloit, WI
    Average Salary: $61,218
    Teaching in Beloit offers a welcoming environment for those seeking to step into the classroom. The district values diverse teaching styles, making it an ideal place for professionals to showcase their skills. With a strong focus on community, educators here often find a supportive network of colleagues.
    Find Substitute Teacher jobs in Beloit, WI


  2. Oshkosh, WI
    Average Salary: $52,011
    Working in Oshkosh means joining a district known for its innovative approaches. Substitutes here benefit from a collaborative culture and ongoing professional development. The city's commitment to education ensures a fulfilling experience for educators.
    Find Substitute Teacher jobs in Oshkosh, WI


  3. Plymouth, WI
    Average Salary: $39,370
    Plymouth provides a friendly setting for educators to make a difference. The district emphasizes a positive work-life balance, offering flexibility in assignments. Teachers here can expect a welcoming community and a supportive professional environment.
    Find Substitute Teacher jobs in Plymouth, WI


  4. Fond du Lac, WI
    Average Salary: $37,829
    Educators in Fond du Lac find a district that values dedication and teamwork. The community’s emphasis on student success creates a dynamic teaching environment. Substitutes here often enjoy a close-knit school culture and a supportive administrative team.
    Find Substitute Teacher jobs in Fond du Lac, WI


  5. Green Bay, WI
    Average Salary: $35,229
    Green Bay offers a vibrant educational landscape for substitute teachers. The district’s commitment to excellence ensures a challenging yet rewarding experience. Substitutes can look forward to a diverse student population and a focus on innovation.
    Find Substitute Teacher jobs in Green Bay, WI


  6. Sheboygan, WI
    Average Salary: $31,917
    Teaching in Sheboygan provides a rewarding experience for those who love working with students. The district supports teachers through various resources and professional development opportunities. Substitutes here can expect a community-oriented approach to education.
    Find Substitute Teacher jobs in Sheboygan, WI


  7. Waupaca, WI
    Average Salary: $31,000
    In Waupaca, substitute teachers find a district that values their contributions. The community’s dedication to student achievement creates a positive teaching environment. Educators here enjoy a supportive atmosphere and a chance to impact young lives.
    Find Substitute Teacher jobs in Waupaca, WI

What are the best paying companies for a Substitute Teacher in Appleton, WI?

The YMCA and Wonderschool offer some of the best pay for substitute teachers in Appleton, WI. Teachers at the YMCA can earn an average salary of around $35,760. Wonderschool provides a competitive average salary of about $31,000. Both companies value their teachers and provide a supportive work environment.
Graph displaying best paying company salaries for Substitute Teacher jobs in Appleton, WI, highlighting YMCA with the highest at $35,760 and Wonderschool with the lowest at $31,000.

  1. YMCA
    Average Salary: $35,760
    YMCA offers substitute teaching positions with a competitive average salary. They focus on community education and provide opportunities for substitute teachers to work across various programs and locations. Their facilities are spread across Appleton and the surrounding areas, offering a diverse work environment.


  2. Wonderschool
    Average Salary: $31,000
    Wonderschool provides substitute teaching jobs with a solid average salary. They connect schools and educators, making it easier to find temporary teaching positions. Their network covers multiple schools in Appleton, giving substitute teachers a range of teaching experiences.

Currently 1,342 Substitute Teacher job openings, nationwide.

View Substitute Teacher Jobs in Appleton, WI

How's the job market for a Substitute Teacher in the US?

Learn what a Substitute Teacher does, how to become one, and understand the job outlook. Get simple steps to start your career as a Substitute Teacher today.
Position
Overview
Substitute Teacher
1,342 Job Openings

Win at hiring.

Visit the help center for any questions.
Contact Support
ReadySetHire icon
©2025 • ReadySetHire