Substitute Teacher Salary in Indianapolis, IN

Updated on May 09, 2025
Position
City
Salary

How much does a Substitute Teacher make in Indianapolis, IN?

The average salary for a Substitute Teacher is $31,584 per year in Indianapolis, IN.

Substitute teachers in Indianapolis, IN, earn a competitive salary. On average, they make around $31,584 per year. This figure can vary based on experience and the specific school district. Many substitute teachers find this role rewarding, as it offers flexibility and the chance to impact many students' lives.

Several factors can influence a substitute teacher's earnings. These include the number of days worked, the school district's pay scale, and the teacher's qualifications. Some districts may offer higher pay for substitutes with advanced degrees or specialized skills. Additionally, working in a high-demand area can lead to more opportunities and potentially higher earnings.

Substitute Teacher jobs in Indianapolis, IN

What are the highest paying cities for a Substitute Teacher near Indianapolis, IN?

Substitute teachers near Indianapolis, IN, can find some of the best pay in Lafayette, where the average salary is $39,613. Gary and South Bend also offer competitive salaries, with averages of $39,039 and $37,303, respectively. These cities provide attractive opportunities for those seeking higher earnings in the substitute teaching field.
Graph displaying highest paying cities salaries for Substitute Teacher jobs near Indianapolis, IN, highlighting Lafayette, IN with the highest at $39,613 and Richmond, IN with the lowest at $28,750.
  1. Lafayette, IN
    Average Salary: $39,613
    In Lafayette, teaching offers a chance to engage with a vibrant community. Schools here value educators who can adapt quickly. Lafayette's schools are known for their supportive environment.
    Find Substitute Teacher jobs in Lafayette, IN


  2. Gary, IN
    Average Salary: $39,039
    Gary provides a dynamic setting for educators. The city's schools focus on innovation and community involvement. Working here means being part of a forward-thinking educational system.
    Find Substitute Teacher jobs in Gary, IN


  3. South Bend, IN
    Average Salary: $37,303
    South Bend is a great place for teaching. The city's schools emphasize collaboration and student success. Educators here enjoy a strong sense of community.
    Find Substitute Teacher jobs in South Bend, IN


  4. Fishers, IN
    Average Salary: $35,000
    Fishers offers a modern approach to education. The schools here are well-funded and focus on technology in the classroom. Teachers in Fishers benefit from a supportive and progressive environment.
    Find Substitute Teacher jobs in Fishers, IN


  5. Fort Wayne, IN
    Average Salary: $34,329
    Fort Wayne provides a diverse teaching environment. The city's schools are committed to excellence and student growth. Educators here work in a community that values education.
    Find Substitute Teacher jobs in Fort Wayne, IN


  6. Carmel, IN
    Average Salary: $32,644
    Carmel is known for its high-quality schools. The community here supports education and values teacher contributions. Working in Carmel means being part of a well-resourced and dedicated school system.
    Find Substitute Teacher jobs in Carmel, IN


  7. Evansville, IN
    Average Salary: $32,238
    Evansville offers a unique teaching experience. The city's schools are focused on creating a positive learning environment. Educators here enjoy a community that supports their professional growth.
    Find Substitute Teacher jobs in Evansville, IN


  8. Anderson, IN
    Average Salary: $29,310
    Anderson provides a welcoming environment for teachers. The schools here are committed to student success and teacher development. Working in Anderson means being part of a caring and supportive educational community.
    Find Substitute Teacher jobs in Anderson, IN


  9. Westfield, IN
    Average Salary: $29,179
    Westfield offers a small-town feel with a big-city commitment to education. The schools here focus on community and student achievement. Teachers here enjoy a supportive and collaborative environment.
    Find Substitute Teacher jobs in Westfield, IN


  10. Richmond, IN
    Average Salary: $28,750
    Richmond provides a nurturing environment for educators. The city's schools emphasize student well-being and academic success. Working in Richmond means being part of a dedicated and supportive educational community.
    Find Substitute Teacher jobs in Richmond, IN

What are the best paying companies for a Substitute Teacher in Indianapolis, IN?

Substitute teachers in Indianapolis can find rewarding opportunities with top-paying employers. The State of Indiana offers competitive salaries, with an average of $37,713 per year. Goodwill Industries also provides a solid income, with an average of $35,000 annually. MSD Wayne Township and Kelly are other notable employers, offering average salaries of $32,026 and $29,866, respectively. These companies value their substitute teachers and provide a stable work environment.
Graph displaying best paying company salaries for Substitute Teacher jobs in Indianapolis, IN, highlighting State of Indiana with the highest at $37,713 and Kelly with the lowest at $29,866.
  1. State of Indiana
    Average Salary: $37,713
    The State of Indiana offers rewarding Substitute Teacher positions. These roles provide flexibility and the opportunity to impact many students. Positions are available across various schools in Indianapolis.


  2. Goodwill Industries
    Average Salary: $35,000
    Goodwill Industries provides Substitute Teacher jobs with a focus on community and skill development. These roles allow teachers to work in diverse environments, helping students gain valuable skills. Goodwill operates multiple locations in Indianapolis.


  3. MSD Wayne Township
    Average Salary: $32,026
    MSD Wayne Township offers Substitute Teacher positions with a strong emphasis on student achievement. Teachers work in a supportive environment, contributing to the academic success of students. The district operates schools throughout Indianapolis.


  4. Kelly
    Average Salary: $29,866
    Kelly provides Substitute Teacher jobs with a focus on flexibility and professional growth. These roles allow teachers to work in various schools, gaining diverse experiences. Kelly operates in multiple locations in Indianapolis.

Currently 2,176 Substitute Teacher job openings, nationwide.

How's the job market for a Substitute Teacher in the US?

Learn what a Substitute Teacher does, how to become one, and understand the job outlook. Get simple steps to start your career as a Substitute Teacher today.
Position
Overview
Substitute Teacher
2,176 Job Openings